Sherman NY Real Estate & Homes for Sale

Don't miss this opportunity to be the new owner of this grand, historical home formerly Plum Door Bed and Breakfast built by the Bordens Milk Company. This house has classic charm with a modern twist. Boasting 5 bedrooms plus a finished basement bedroom/ in-law suite with private entrance, bath and kitchen. Tons of updates including a newly built sun room, perfect for enjoying a cup of coffee or tea next to a cozy fire, new windows, newer on-demand hot water tank and boiler. Included with property is a 40x40 pole barn with 3 bays. Hot tub and 9ft Deep, in-ground pool with new pool heater, surrounded by 5 story deck including a covered patio perfect for summer get-togethers and BBQ's. The newly constructed tree house will provide hours of fun. Store all your extra stuff in the extra outbuilding at the back of the property. There is also a finished attic with lots of storage currently used as a game room or could be used as an extra bedroom. Conveniently located near shopping, restaurants, school and Highway close to Lake Erie and Chautauqua Lake. Plenty of room to run, play and swim this beautiful 1.7 acres corner lot nestled in the heart of Sherman.

Welcome to your new homestead! This cozy 1440 sq ft 2 bedroom 1 bath home on 3.9 acres offers plenty of room to grow a garden and have room for some animals. The roomy kitchen features hardwood cabinets with plenty of counter space. There is a large living room with a wood-burning stove. There is a pull-down staircase to the 12X48 attic storage area. You will find a lovely concrete front patio area. The detached combination barn and garage feature a 24 x 32 horse barn with 4 stalls. A 16 x 24 garage with 2 7x7 overhead doors and a 30 x 32 garage with an 8 x 8 overhead door and a 10 x 32 loft.

Welcome to your dream retreat! Located just minutes away from peaceful shores of Findley Lake and the excitement of Peek 'n Peak Resort, outdoor enthusiasts will love the proximity to snowmobile trails, skiing, hiking, hunting, boating and other recreational activities.Nestled on 18.8 acres of picturesque land, this cozy 3 bedroom, 1.5 bath abode provides rustic charm and modern amenities, offering the perfect blend of tranquility and adventure. Features new wood barn for storage or workshop, spacious front deck, and inviting back deck, you'll have ample space to relax and take in the stunning surroundings. Step inside to discover a warm and inviting interior featuring a wood burning fireplace, perfect for cozying up after a day on the ski slopes or exploring the snowmobile trails that lead straight to Pine Junction. The open floor plan seamlessly connects the living, dining, and kitchen areas, providing an ideal space for entertaining or relaxing with loved ones. With its prime location and fully furnished set up this home presents an excellent opportunity for Airbnb hosting, ready to welcome guests and provide unforgettable experiences. Ask for home updates, to many to list!

LARGE COMMERCIAL BUILDING ON 3 ACRES**** AFTER DECADES OF BUSINESS THE SHERMAN CENTRAL TRACTOR HAS CLOSED AND WILL SELL COMMERCIAL PROPERTY LOCATED AT 122 KENDRICK SHERMAN NY. IF YOU ARE LOOKING FOR A LOARGE COMMERCIAL SPACE / WAREHOUSE / POSSIBLE INDOOR STORAGE FACILITY HERE IT IS. LOCATED JUST OFF 86 THIS BUILDING IS FULL OF POTENTIAL AND BUSINESS POSSIBILITIES. ONE PART IS APPROX. 52FT X 100FT AND THE ADDITION IS APPROX. 40FT X 100FT. THIS PIECE IS LOCATED 20 MINUTES FROM JAMESTOWN AND 20 MINUTES FROM ERIE. SITS ON APPROX. 4 ACRES WITH THE EXTRA 3 ACRE PARCEL. WHETHER YOU ARE PUTTING IN AN ANTIQUE CO-OP / INSIDE STORAGE / WAREHOUSE / ETC. THIS BUILDING WITH A LITTLE TLC WILL PROVIDE PLENTY OF POTENTIAL.

Check out this private retreat situated on over 28 acres. This custom 3 bed 3 bath Barndominium was built in 2017. Nestled into the woods well off the road. Exterior features a large pond, Covered front porch, Metal siding and roof for low maintenance, attached garage and a detached shed. First floor has a great open concept with large fireplace, vaulted ceilings, Kitchen with island and first floor Bedroom/bathroom/laundry. Two second floor wings both set up as primary suites with full baths. House has radiant in floor heat with on demand hot water. Excellent Hunting and close proximity to Peek n Peak resort.

Two story, 2700 square foot commercial building in the heart of the village of Sherman with many updates inside and out. The first floor tenant operates a liquor store with great space, storage and lighting throughout. The second floor has a three bedroom apartment with one full bath, large kitchen area, laundry room, and living room. There are 3 doorways into the apartment with 2 doorways from an exterior entrance and stairway on Main Street and one exterior door from the rear bedroom to a stairway at the back of the building. The front street entrance has been updated with a new awning and lighting through village grants. Property has 2 solid sources of income on a busy village street. A must see for any investor!!

Unique, historical mill in the heart of the village of Sherman. This 9756 square foot space has 3 levels and has had many improvements that must been seen and appreciated. The western exterior door way leads into an office area with 2 bathrooms and a kitchen area. Moving into the shop area you will see high ceilings that have been gutted with a blower system and a 3 bay loading area. The rear storage room on this level has sleeving for various wood pieces and runs the length of the building. A $20,000 grant was obtained to make exterior improvements. The second floor has a old grain area with interesting space potential as well as a large open work and cabinet area. There is new and updated flooring throughout with a handy compressor. The dry basement has plenty of storage, a rear exterior door and electronical panels with 500 amp service. This space has many possibilities and just needs your vision.

House has newer boiler, vinyl siding, blown in insulation and metal roof. Newer deck.

Excellent buildable property ideally located just off the Sherman Exit from I-86. The property has nearly 2 acres of open, buildable ground immediately adjacent to Prospect Road with the balance of the property being wooded. It is zoned Commercial and many business opportunities are available here. Not into the commercial aspect? The property also has hunting opportunities for deer and turkey and could be a great spot to access both Chautauqua Lake and Lake Erie from for your boating and fishing pleasures! 9+ vacant acres Zoned Highway Commercial with multiple usages allowed. A complete list is available and extensive. Village Water and Sewer along with electric and gas lines can be run to this parcel when developed. About 2 acres are level and clear and "shovel ready" with great visibility from high traffic on both Route 86 and 76. The balance is forest and scenic. Super Location for a homesite as well. Potential unlimited!