Cooperstown NY Real Estate & Homes for Sale

The perfect blend of historic charm/modern living minutes from Cooperstown! 1825 federal manor home built by Scottish stone mason Scottie Jamie in herringbone pattern field stone. Recently renovated and meticulously maintained w/ a large basement, a geothermal system provides heat/air conditioning. Spacious upstairs boasts large bdrms including ensuite and bonus room with exposed field stone wall/original hdwod floors. Downstairs consists of a modern kitchen, formal living room, large additional room (easily a bedroom, formal dining room, office) and a family room w/ pellet stove, laundry rm and bath. Rear of the home features a summer kitchen, storage areas and staircase to the attic. Situated on 5 acres, 2+ acres cleared/fenced in with a custom welded driveway gate. High spd internet

Charming 3 bed, 2 bath, year 'round, renovated lake cottage with 126' of direct lake front and 115' of stream front. With its own point allowing for panoramic views of Otsego Lake, and a full list of major capital improvements, this once in a lifetime gem is move-in ready. No expense was spared in the construction of this delightful home. As lovely and cozy as it is inside, the true magic lies in the beauty of the outdoor space and the community within this incredible location, which is only 6 miles from the village of Cooperstown. This home was completely gutted to the studs, reframed, and rebuilt, keeping as many original features in place as possible. The end result is an effortless blending of old and new, with all expected modern amenities, allowing for an ultra functional, warm living space. A rare and wonderful feature of this home is its level access from the road to the home and lake. This is a home to love for a lifetime and will represents a lifestyle like no other. An elevation survey has been done ~ this property is not in a flood plain.Owner is NY state licensed real estate broker.

This little jewel box was built in 1902 and used exclusively by the same family as a seasonal home until 2019. 117 years later, it was purchased and completely renovated, sparing no expense. Favorite features of this property are its level access from the road to the house and lake ~ a rarity on Glimmerglass! A small tranquil stream runs along the north boundary, and is flanked by pretty flower gardens. The property juts out to a point, where the stream and lake converge. Here you'll enjoy spectacular panoramic lake views of our glistening waters, Sleeping Lion Mountain, farmlands & mountains to the east as well as long views to the south. A rustic fire pit at the point serves as a lovely end of day spot to unwind and gather with friends. The home has undergone a total transformation, while retaining many of the special original features, harmoniously blending old with new. Enjoy lazy lake days ~ coffee on the porch at sunrise, cool your feet in the water after sunning on the deck, cocktails on the dock at dusk, dinner al fresco or boat into town, a fire at the point, and a soak in the hot tub at days' end. A LIFESTYLE one can get used to! An efficient kitchen with creamy white cabinets & brick-tiled backsplash, opens to the dining room, formal entry, & living room, and packs plenty of storage. A deep apron sink is outfitted with solid brass fixtures. Counters are Ceasarstone Quartz in a milky white with subtle gold streaks. Beautiful Cafe' appliances (dual fuel oven/range, convection microwave oven, 3 tier dishwasher, & counter-depth pantry style refrigerator/freezer), unify the space. The rustic tiled floors are radiant heated on their own zone, and a sunny skylight along with new recessed & pendant lighting on dimmer switches, set a warm ambient tone. A spacious island/counter bar, provides lots of room for meal prep, and ample space to lay out your appetizers, making entertaining a breeze! New Anderson sliding doors in the living room are flanked by original windows with pretty stained glass, and lead to the covered porch where you can enjoy the outdoors in any weather! A 3-sided Lopi fireplace runs off a thermostat and heats the entire home. All windows are new Andersons (most are tilt-in), customized with brass lock mechanisms. The downstairs bedroom has an exposed beam ceiling, original wood floors, and original doors with a south facing lake view and a new en-suite full bath with heated laminate flooring, new shower enclosure, vanity, awning window, and efficient flush toilet. The original staircase remains in tact. Only its treads were refinished and a runner was added. At the top of the stairs you'll be greeted with breathtaking lake views through new 12 x 6 sliding Marvin windows which were added to the room. The primary bedroom is a spacious room with high ceilings, ceiling fan, its own gas fireplace and mirrored closet doors reflecting the lake. Original floors remain throughout the entire 2nd floor. The other second floor bedroom is storybook sweet with two windows, small closet, a knotty pine feature wall painted navy blue, and has south-facing lake views. The upstairs bath blends old with new ~ the original oversized porcelain tub with custom frameless glass shower enclosure, new vanity, original knotty pine and bead board walls along with a custom fit wall mirror, a fun chandelier & sconce wall lighting. ALL systems were replaced. Electric, Plumbing, Insulation, Heat, Rinnai On-Demand Hot Water Heater, Water Softening System, UV Water Filtration System and Reverse Osmosis Drinking Water Filtration System. New Reznor Heater in the basement. An addition was added to the front of the home providing a cozy heated entry for coats, shoes, storage.Garage is brand new. Both structures have NEW cement board siding. The porch was rebuilt with new flooring, rails, stairs and columns. The deck is new and sun-drenched! Parking for up to 4 cars. Truly a GLORIOUS home! *Owner is NYS License Real Estate Broker.

Nestled atop a gentle slope, overlooking the serene Otsego Lake, this charming 4-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom home offers an unparalleled blend of nostalgic charm and tranquility. Situated on just over 5 acres in the Cooperstown school district, the property boasts stunning panoramic lake views and a cozy ambiance. Inside, rich hardwood floors flow throughout the home, complementing the kitchen with its exposed beams. A spacious mudroom adds convenience, while the tidy basement offers storage with unlimited potential. Outside, a patio and deck provide the perfect spots to enjoy the landscape, while a two-car garage and outbuilding ensures ample storage space. With its elegant design and breathtaking views, this home presents a rare opportunity. Just minutes from the heart of Cooperstown. Don't miss your chance to make this charming home yours!

Welcome to this charming 1988 three bedroom, three bath home situated on 1.8 acres of picturesque land. This property boasts a large yard with beautiful perennials, and woods. With plenty of parking space, a two car garage, shed, and barn, there is ample room for storage and activities. Inside, you will find a spacious Great Room style living room, dining area, and kitchen. The kitchen features stainless-steel appliances, laminate counters, spacious cabinetry, a refrigerator, electric stove, and a large center island. The cozy living room is equipped with a propane heat stove and offers access to both front and back covered porches with breathtaking views of the countryside. With 1,764 square feet of living space, this house offers plenty of room for work and play. Other features include broadband high-speed internet, Cooperstown Schools, and convenient access to Cooperstown, Oneonta, US-20, and I-88. Offered to settle an estate, this affordable home is a great opportunity for those looking for a cozy retreat in a convenient location. Don't miss out on this unique property - schedule a showing today!

Situated just outside of the renowned, quintessential Cooperstown and tucked away in a most bucolic setting at the end of a long driveway, you'll find a paradise like no other. 134 verdant acres with splendid views offers divine tranquility. Helicopter in for a landing in one of the open fields. You might want to carve out trails for X-Country Skiing. This jewel of a cottage features wide plank floors, fireplaced great room, oversized screened porch for dining or just ''being.'' Across the field you'll find a picturesque barn complex and an additional cabin transformed into a sauna with picture window. Venture into town and relax by Otsego Lake or meander to the shops and restaurants. Enjoy a round of golf, The Glimmerglass Opera and last but not least, The National Baseball Hall of Fame.

(9493) Cherish this appealing Post & Beam Schoolhouse enhanced by rural view. Promising 1846 home offering original millwork, doors, wainscoting, and blackboards. Updated electric. Restore to your needs. Just 2 miles East of Cooperstown. Cooperstown Schools. Hubbell's Exclusive.

NEW CONSTRUCTION, be the first to reside in this custom built home! Situated as the second to last house, on a private dead end road, providing complete peace and quiet. One level living at it's finest, with a mudroom/foyer that can be accessed from outside or the attached two car garage, beautiful kitchen with breakfast bar that is open to a large living area, full bath between two bedrooms, and a master bedroom with full bath and walk-in closet. There are separate "Split" heating/cooling systems in each room of the house, providing highly efficient temperature control throughout. French doors in the living area lead to a timber frame covered porch, the perfect spot to entertain or simply enjoy the views and sounds of the small babbling creek that passes through the property. The nearly 19 acres are a perfect balance of open and wooded, with spectacular views. Located in a country setting, and only fifteen minutes to the historic Village of Cooperstown.

Curb appeal plus! The twin first and second floor wrap-around porches are just the beginning! Gorgeous interior features well appointed eat-in kitchen with quartz countertops, living room with exposed beams at ceiling and hardwood floors, and half bath with stack laundry. Two bedrooms with expansive closets and office upstairs, all sharing full tile bath. Owner-built attached garage ties seamlessly to home as if it has always been there, and offers upscale second floor efficiency unit for owner or tenant! Cathedral ceiling, custom cabinets, solid surface counters, and tile bath- a perfect Cooperstown efficiency! The entire home was redone in 2007. Make your appointment to see this home which you will find to be move-in ready, with quality improvements, and upgrades everywhere you look, inside and out. Metal roof, gutters, heating and electrical, and a new Rennai heating unit was just installed for second floor efficiency apartment. Outside, you will find an 18'x30' deck, and a surprisingly spacious and level, fully fenced backyard. This versatile home will appeal to owner-occupants and investors alike!

Incredible opportunity for re-development in a choice location! This property is situated in a prime location and shares a controlled intersection with the renowned Cooperstown Dreams Park, making it an ideal investment. Currently, three income-generating buildings are spread across three separate parcels, providing potential revenue streams. With nearly 28 acres of land available, ample space exists for expansion or reimagining the property to suit your needs. This location is particularly appealing for those familiar with Maskots or anyone looking for a high-traffic site that benefits from a concentrated 16-week season. Additionally, the property's proximity to Cooperstown and the Glimmerglass Opera House offers year-round appeal, attracting visitors from around the world who are drawn to the local historical attractions. Whether you envision establishing a spa, restaurant, local destination wedding venue, or even adding more ball fields, this property offers endless possibilities. An additional 20+/- acres are available adjacent to the existing land. Come and explore everything this property has to offer and let your imagination run wild with its potential.

A barndominium! Well-kept, too. All buildings are new since 2000. The main structure is 72x84', has 6 box stalls, a 1000ft2 residence, and room enough left over for a small arena. Some of that is used now as a farm shop. If you wanted more living space, some modifications to the roof trusses could double the living space or you could expand into the rest of the barn. As it stands now, there is a kitchen/dining area, a large summer room, a living room, a professional office (which might be a bedroom for someone else), a study, and 2 more bedrooms plus the bath. Water is from a 200 drilled well and there is a 1200gallon septic. Heat is electric baseboard, but they prefer to use a wood stove and a propane backup. Walls are real wood paneling and floors carpet or laminate. Very comfortable, efficient and there's zero commute. A second barn is 40x50' and has room for 8 box stalls, though there are just two now. One is a mare/foal stall, double-sized. The rest is used as a run-in area. Wings on either side provide space to store vehicles and farm machinery There are regular run-in sheds as well, 10x30', 10x12' and 10x10'. And a sand outdoor arena for training. This is pipe-fenced. There are several frost-free hydrants to make your life easier when watering. You will love the area. The farm is located on a road which becomes seasonal a short distance beyond the property. Many of the neighbors live there only seasonally. So you find all the peace and quiet anyone could ask for. It is scenic, with beautiful area views everywhere. Somewhat rolling topography except in the area surrounding the buildings , which has flat and gravelly soils. And of course, it is close to the many amenities of Cooperstown. If you need a larger city and big box stores, Oneonta is 20 minutes away and there are others which are closer. It's a great area. The land is mostly tillable, and is rented to nearby Menonite farmers. A small stream runs though. There is a total of 13 acres with 1415' feet of road frontage and is priced at $300000. An adjoining 13 acres can be added, which would increase the price only $25000 more. And if you want even more land, there is an adjoining neighbor who would agree to sell. Taxes on everything are $2800. Expecdt a June 1 closing to allow an orderly transition.

A barndominium! Well-kept, too. All buildings are new since 2000. The main structure is 72x84', has 6 box stalls, a 1000ft2 residence, and room enough left over for a small arena. Some of that is used now as a farm shop. If you wanted more living space, some modifications to the roof trusses could double the living space or you could expand into the rest of the barn. As it stands now, there is a kitchen/dining area, a large summer room, a living room, a professional office (which might be a bedroom for someone else), a study, and 2 more bedrooms plus the bath. Water is from a 200 drilled well and there is a 1200gallon septic. Heat is electric baseboard, but they prefer to use a wood stove and a propane backup. Walls are real wood paneling and floors carpet or laminate. Very comfortable, efficient and there's zero commute. A second barn is 40x50' and has room for 8 box stalls, though there are just two now. One is a mare/foal stall, double-sized. The rest is used as a run-in area. Wings on either side provide space to store vehicles and farm machinery There are regular run-in sheds as well, 10x30', 10x12' and 10x10'. And a sand outdoor arena for training. This is pipe-fenced. There are several frost-free hydrants to make your life easier when watering. You will love the area. The farm is located on a road which becomes seasonal a short distance beyond the property. Many of the neighbors live there only seasonally. So you find all the peace and quiet anyone could ask for. It is scenic, with beautiful area views everywhere. Somewhat rolling topography except in the area surrounding the buildings , which has flat and gravelly soils. And of course, it is close to the many amenities of Cooperstown. If you need a larger city and big box stores, Oneonta is 20 minutes away and there are others which are closer. It's a great area. The land is mostly tillable, and is rented to nearby Menonite farmers. A small stream runs though. There is a total of 26.14 acres. This is broken down into 2 parcels, 13 acres each, purchased at separate times from different owners The 13 acres with the buildings has 1415' feet of road frontage and is priced at $300000. The adjoining 13 acres has no buildings and has a bit under 500' of frontage and is priced at $50000. If you want both there is a discount: $325000 for everything. And if you want more land, there is an adjoining neighbor who would agree to sell. Taxes on everything are $2800. For an orderly transition, expect to close June 1st.

Distinctive Cooperstown rambler, true mid-century classic American home. 6+ ac near Otsego Lake. 1-story brick offers open concept layout in tranquil wooded setting. 4 bdrms, 3 bthrms, hm offc, 2 decks. Elegant lvng rm w handsome black brick hearth & doors to deck. Prmry ste private retreat w bath, hall of closets & doors to deck. Formal dng rm w bespoke red fabric wall treatments & window to wooded acreage. Well-designed kitchen w chef's dream peninsula, copious counter space & freshly painted glass-door cupboards. Spacious bkfst area, w windows. Sunken family room, library-themed guest bdrm, + full bathroom. Laundry, storage, a full bsmnt & 2-car+ dtchd grg. Wooded acreage creating sense of total privacy, (invisible fence). Near Leatherstocking Golf Course & Otesaga Hotel, The Farmers' Museum & Fenimore Art Museum, shops, bars, & restaurants, The Baseball Hall of Fame, & Alice Busch Opera Theatre/Glimmerglass Festival. Close to everything, yet, w a great sense of privacy.

Distinctive Cooperstown rambler, a true mid-century classic American home. On 6+ acres near Otsego Lake, 1-story brick home offers open concept layout in tranquil wooded setting. 4 bdrms, 3 bthrms, home office, 2 decks, perfect for comfortable living & entertaining. Centered on elegant living room w handsome black brick hearth & doors to deck. Primary suite is private retreat w bath, hall of closets & doors to deck. Formal dining room w bespoke red fabric wall treatments. Well-designed kitchen w chefs dream peninsula, copious counter space, & freshly painted glass-door cupboards. Spacious family dining area, w windows to deck. Sunken family room, library-themed guest bdrm, + full bathroom. Laundry, storage, a full basement, 2-car+ dtchd grg. The wooded acreage is fantastic, creating sense of total privacy, (invisible fence for dog installed). Near Leatherstocking Golf Course & Otesaga Hotel, The Farmers Museum & Fenimore Art Museum. Close to town w its shops, bars, & restaurants, and, The Baseball Hall of Fame, and Alice Busch Opera Theatre home of Glimmerglass Festival. Ideally located, its close to everything. And yet, w a great sense of privacy.

Welcome home to your next address, this 4-5 bedroom home with large primary rooms, with the character of yesterday, First floor has new hardwoods installed Great village locations close to hospital and downtown. Large two stall, two story garage with a great inground pool for all the hot summer days. This is a one of kind home. With a first and second floor large storage room and large bedrooms this is for sure a home for your personal touches. On demand hot water tank installed for home,. Newer Roof installed

The perfect blend of historic charm and modern living just minutes from Cooperstown, schools and Bassett Hospital! The 1825 federal manor home was built by Scottish stone mason Scottie Jamie in herringbone pattern field stone. Recently renovated and meticulously maintained with a large basement, a geothermal system provides heat/air conditioning. The upstairs has 3 large bedrooms, 2 modern bathrooms including an ensuite bathroom with shower, tub, heated floor. Additional family room on the second floor features a beautifully restored exposed field stone wall and refinished original hardwood flooring. The downstairs consists of a formal living room, large additional room (easily a bedroom, formal dining room, office) and a family room with a pellet stove. The large kitchen has a 6-burner gas stove and stainless appliances. The laundry room has a new Electrolux washer/dryer and is next to the bathroom on the first floor. The back of the home features a summer kitchen, large storage areas and staircase to the attic. Situated on 5 beautiful acres, including over 2 acres cleared and fenced in with a custom welded driveway gate. High speed internet.

With plans in motion and the basics in place, the opportunity to influence the finishes and details of this luxury property is yours. Set against the idyllic backdrop of Cooperstown, NY this beautiful home is in the midst of a high-end renovation, with every detail carefully considered. The property is zoned to allow for mixed use only minutes from the village.At the heart of this evolving estate is a carefully rejuvenated timber framed barn redesigned as a living space. The basics are done and include in floor radiant heat, framing for 3 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, and an oversized garage/boat storage. The original home features state of the art mechanicals and comfort considerations, including full spray foam insulation, while retaining the period aesthetic awaiting completion. Because the seller has spared no expense in preparing the ground work for the final stages of this restoration, the details are too numerous to list here. This is an exciting project entering the final stages with business use possibilities. Please inquire for details and a list of allowed commercial uses.

With plans in motion and the basics in place, the opportunity to influence the finishes of this luxury property is yours. Set in idyllic Cooperstown, in the midst of a high-end renovation, with every detail carefully considered. The property is zoned to allow for mixed use only minutes from the village.At the heart of this evolving estate is a rejuvenated timber framed barn redesigned as a living space, including in-floor radiant heat, framing for 3 bdrms and 3 baths, and garage/boat storage. The original home features state of the art mechanicals and comfort considerations, including full spray foam insulation. The details are too numerous to list here. This is an exciting project entering the final stages with business use possibilities.

This 4-bedroom Colonial in the village of Cooperstown offers a unique chance to own a fully renovated historic home. The house has been completely renovated from top to bottom while maintaining its original character and incorporating a modern touch. The house has brand-new plumbing, electric, heating systems, and the added luxury of radiant floor heat in the upstairs bathrooms. The practical side of modern living is covered; along with the Wi-Fi, high-speed internet ports are hardwired into every room of the house. The new owner can also choose their own custom countertops and sinks for the kitchen and bathrooms, which will be installed for free before closing! Positioned in a quiet suburban neighborhood and just a 5-minute walk from Main Street's shopping and dining, as well as the Baseball Hall of Fame, the location cannot be beaten. Beyond being a residence, this property is well-suited for a high-end rental, given its proximity to downtown, four blocks to Otsego Lake, 10 minutes to the Cooperstown Dreams Park, and just 300 feet from Doubleday Field. Don't miss this rare chance to own a fully renovated historic home in Cooperstown!

Bring your fishing poles! Premier location on Oaks Creek!! Enjoy this low maintenance ranch, situated nicely on 2 plus acres for chickens, goats, sheep or the family dog! Relax and listen to babbling sounds of Oaks Creek! This spacious ranch has an open floor plan, 3 bedroom and 2 bath, comfy living room, bright kitchen with new counter tops and a sweet dining area overlooking the back deck and expansive yard. Or rock the afternoon away of the covered front porch! Bonus 2 car garage and workshop complete this perfect property for year round living, Summer vacationing or rental investment. The garage can be easily converted into an apartment for income or guest. Close to Cooperstown Village, Bassett Hospital, Clarks Sports Center and Brookwood School.

Huge Price Reduction .... Owner says SELL ! Please bring all offers . What a great home, a raised ranch with a full basement that could become your man cave, workshop, or additional living space. 3 bedroom 2 bath home with Cooperstown Dream Park rental history, could be a great investment . Secluded location off the beaten path but only 9 mins to the Cooperstown action. 3.21 wooded acres for your recreation needs. Nice wrap around deck and yard . Storage shed included

Put your mark on this 3-bedroom home nestled high in the woods. Great views from every room. An incredible peaceful retreat after a day of work.

Lovingly designed in the time-honored traditional farmhouse style, this stately property is set on 33+ secluded acres full of adventure overlooking Otsego Lake. Tastefully adorned in true era embellishments, featuring wide plank hardwood underfoot, two wood burning fireplaces, rustic hardware and lighting throughout, and exposed beams overhead. Naturally lit country kitchen with quaint breakfast nook, formal dining room with flooring obtained from an 1800s schoolhouse, and inviting family room all displaying natures sprawling vistas. Second story roomy ensuite primary with antiquated clawfoot tub, two additional bedrooms, full bath and walk up access to the charming finished attic space. Mudroom entry to an attached 2 car garage with walkout access to the backyard with blue stone patio and in-ground heated pool set to enjoy the hill top lake views. The grounds include a 12x24 barn all set up with electric, water and a paddock area. Plenty of recreational privacy for hunting, hiking, and outdoor play. Only a mile to Glimmerglass State Park, 10 min to Otsego Golf club.

Designed in the time-honored traditional farmhouse style, this stately property is set on 33+ secluded acres full of adventure overlooking Otsego Lake. Tastefully adorned in true era embellishments featuring wide plank hardwood, wood burning fireplaces, and exposed beams overhead. Naturally lit eat-in country kitchen, formal dining room with flooring obtained from an 1800's schoolhouse, and inviting family room all displaying nature's vistas. Second story ensuite primary with antiquated clawfoot tub. Charming finished attic space, mudroom entry to the 2 car garage. Blue stone patio area w/heated pool. Includes a 12x24 barn all set up with electric, water and a paddock. Plenty of privacy for hunting, hiking and outdoor play, only a mile to Glimmerglass State Park,10 min to Otsego Golf club