Montello WI Real Estate & Homes for Sale

Nestled on five secluded wooded acres, this inviting property comprises two units. Unit 1 features a spacious living area, three bedrooms, and a full bathroom, while Unit 2 offers a generous family room, two bedrooms, and a full bathroom. Both units boast access to a shared laundry room and come equipped with an attached garage. Currently fully leased with a proven rental history, this property offers the opportunity for passive income from reliable tenants. Alternatively, consider occupying one unit while utilizing the rental income from the other to offset your mortgage expenses.

NO SHOWINGS UNTIL 4/15: YOU'LL NEVER FIND A PROPERTY WITH MORE SPECTACULAR WIDE WATER VIEWS: Unique opportunity, this immaculate secluded cottage is tucked into the hillside with expansive sunset views and sandy waterfront. You'll be impressed with quality and character, this 2 bed 2 bath home has open concept kitchen/living/dining area. New kitchen in 2020 complete with appliances & custom Amish cabinetry. Living area has walkout to a screen porch for seasonal enjoyment overlooking this great 2200 acre fishing/ boating lake. Lower level has walkout to the lake, guest quarters with updated bath also amazing panoramic views. Enjoy the private setting from a patio at the sandy shoreline. Updates include new flooring, roof, decking and drilled well, situated on a private, large .8 acre lot.

Enjoy country living close to town!! You snooze you lose with this chance. Beautifully maintained 3 bedroom 2 bathroom home with a huge kitchen fit for a chef. The large open floor plan offers plenty of room for whatever your heart desires with 2 living rooms. If the attached garage isn't enough. The huge second garage is sure to have plenty of room for all your toys. Open house April 5th 4pm-6pm, April 6th 10 am - 1pm, April 7th Noon -2pm

WELCOME TO THE LAKE! Your opportunity to own on this amazing 5000 acre fishing/ boating lake in the heart of South Central Wisconsin. The home has the charm of yesteryear with original maple flooring and cabinetry in the kitchen. The bright living area features great wide water views and has updated flooring, lighting and paint. Baths have new fixtures and flooring and completely updated down to the studs. Heating/cooling efficent.. Mechanical improvements include new forced air heating/ central air cooling and water filtration system systems with other recent updates of drilled well, holding tank, electrical, sump pump w/ battery backup, siding and windows. The shoreline has professionally installed rip-rap. A wonderful year round lakefront retreat for the whole family.

Cute, Cozy and ready for you to call Home. This 2 story home sits in the City of Montello with easy access to everything town has to offer. Main floor bedroom with two additional bedrooms upstairs. Large laundry and mud room on main level and an unfinished basement for all your storage needs. Kitchen and Bathroom remodel is already done for you. Hardwood floors helps the past meet the present. Adorable covered porch for your morning coffee and a glass/screen house for outdoor entertaining. 2 car detached garage and a concrete pad for extra parking with a basketball hoop. Access to garage and drive are on Central Ave (all measurements are approx)

Enjoy the peace and quite of country living. Well maintained 2005 manufactured 3 bedroom / 2 bath home on 18+ acres. Large kitchen, formal dining and living area, 3 spacious bedrooms and main floor laundry. Large back deck for entertaining. 30 x 40 heated attached garage. All this off the road! Close to Montello. Also includes Tax Parcel #024-00665-0005

Welcome to Lakefront Living! Nestled on the shores of full rec Montello Lake, this 4-bedroom, 3-bath home invites you to embrace waterfront tranquility. Expansive and airy, it offers stunning lake views from multiple vantage points. Enjoy your morning coffee or evening cocktail on the covered deck or patio area overlooking the spacious backyard that merges seamlessly with the lakes allure. Walk-out lower level. An expansive 37x32 unfinished bonus room on the upper level presents endless possibilities for a workshop or storage. 32x26 attached garage with a 30x25 recreational storage garage, perfectly accommodating all your lake toys and boats. While the home boasts charm, it awaits your personal touch to modernize its timeless appeal. Home comes turn key and move in ready. Roof 2021

Open House Sat 4/13 11-1! The LAKE LIFE you've longed for! Move right into this year round beautiful waterfront ranch! Wall of windows overlooks your 62ft of pristine waterfront on 5013 acre Lake Puckaway! This 2 bdrm, 3 bath, 2154 sqft beauty has a touch of an "up north" cabin feel yet modern amenities, stone gas frplc & wide open flrplan-big kitchen island to entertain at! Relax on the big wraparound deck! Entertain in walkout LL fmly rm w/screened porch &hot tub! Add egress window in LL den to make 3rd bdrm! 1/2 acre lot offers towering trees for added privacy, 2 firepits, shed & massive 3 car gar perfect for your summer & winter toys + you can build an additional outbuilding! Bring your boats, UTVs & snowmobiles! Your pier w/boat lift &topper await! Furniture Avl! VRP $449,900-$469,900

Nestled on the serene shores of Lake Emery, this delightful 1,000 square foot cottage offers a peaceful retreat in Montello, WI. Boasting a quaint and cozy atmosphere, this home features 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom, making it the perfect sanctuary for those seeking a tranquil lakeside living experience. As you step inside, you'll be greeted by a beautifully remodeled kitchen that serves as the heart of this home. The kitchen shines with white shaker cabinets, a stylish tiled backsplash, and stunning countertops, providing both beauty and functionality. Whether you're preparing a family meal or entertaining guests, this kitchen is sure to inspire your culinary creativity. Make this retreat yours today! $525 UHP Warranty is included.

3 bed, 2 full bath 16x80 mobile home in Duck Inn Mobile Home Park with access to Puckaway. Roof was new in 2023. Very clean and well maintained. This location offers you the conveniences of stores and a variety of restaurants also close by. Make this your year-round home or perfect weekend getaway. Lot rent is $450/month, or $400/month if paid in full by the 5th of each month. Lot rent includes water, septic and garbage pick-up. Owner does their own lawn maintenance and snow removal. Buyers must receive park approval. Room sizes are approx, buyer to verify if important. Seller is selling property AS IS.

A unique opportunity to own on this great 2200 acre fishing and boating lake, several thousand feet of finished living space, several hundred feet of lakeshore on an acre of land, complete with your own boat landing. Turn this historic restaurant into your own personal family gathering property, endless potential with over 8000 sq ft of living space. Property boasts a huge living area with great views overlooking the lake. A commercial kitchen any chef would love. A beautiful horseshoe bar for entertaining. Partition off the living area and continue to use or lease the historic bar/restaurant for income generating potential. A gentle slope to water's edge offers a boat landing and place for multiple piers. An amazing property with potential for a myriad of uses.

Spacious 5-bedroom home offers 120ft of frontage on Lake Puckaway. Enjoy the view of the lake from the deck, providing the perfect backdrop for your relaxation and entertainment. Cozy up by the free-standing wood stove in the living room. With a newer fence, water heater, flooring, and roof, this home is move-in ready and designed for easy living with 4.5 acres to enjoy. The attached 2-car garage and additional 30 x 40 pole building offer ample storage space for your toys and equipment to explore all the hunting fishing and watersports Lake Puckaway has to offer. Don't miss out on the opportunity to own a property with waterfront views!

Spacious 5-bedroom home offers 120ft of frontage on Lake Puckaway. Enjoy the view of the lake from the deck, providing the perfect backdrop for your relaxation and entertainment. Cozy up by the free-standing wood stove in the living room. With a newer fence, water heater, flooring, and roof, this home is move-in ready and designed for easy living with 4.5 acres to enjoy. The attached 2-car garage and additional 30 x 40 pole building offer ample storage space for your toys and equipment to explore all the hunting fishing and watersports Lake Puckaway has to offer. Don't miss out on the opportunity to own a property with waterfront views!

Country log home just minutes from Montello. Nestled in the woods this 3 bedroom / 2 bath home offers a cozy atmosphere to relax. Main floor hosts open concept living, kitchen, dining area, bedroom and full bath. Loft area is 20 x 17 and makes a perfect 3rd bedroom. Walkout lower level offers a family room, bedroom, full bath and laundry room. All appliances and most furniture and furnishings will stay. All on your 3 acre wooded parcel. 30x40 detached pole building. Relax and enjoy nature while you sit on the wrap around deck.

Get ready for a summer of fun in the sun! Own your own condo just off of the shores of of Lake Puckaway. Wildlife galore! Outstanding fishing including state record Northern Pike! 2 Bed, 1 Bath - nice open floor plan. New pier & an included boat slip. Heated inground pool! Restaurant within walking distance. Condo is currently enrolled in the association's optional rental program. Super easy to rent it out while you aren't using it - the association handles everything for you! Less than an hour from Wisconsin Dells! Condo could be used year round but the water is off from Oct 15 - April 1st. Condo fees of $2,500 due yearly in April.

Everything is BETTER at the LAKE! Beautiful "like new" waterfront home on Buffalo Lake in Montello. With views from every room, this 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath, home is sure to please. This home offers; open concept design, first floor primary bedroom with attached bath/closet, A/C unit (Ductless Mini-split), 2 car attached garage, finished walkout LL with 2 bedrooms, full bath, laundry room, and family room. Enjoy nature outside by the fire pit or on the pier, or entertain inside by the cozy wood burning fireplace! This lake offers great fishing and an abundance of wildlife!

This is a turn key property and is just waiting for you to come and enjoy!! Sit on your large two tiered deck, relax and enjoy the view that Lake Puckaway has to offer you. Many updates such as furnace, deck, central air, all new windows, stove and refrigerator. Open concept living, kitchen and dining area. The electrical has just been updated to a 200 amp service and the home was completely remodeled except for the guest bathroom. 2 storage sheds for all of your toys. Everything is done for you, except for you to come and enjoy lake life. Just come and enjoy lake life!

Discover the epitome of rural luxury on this expansive 228-acre property. The well-kept farmhouse stands as a testament to exquisite craftsmanship. The home welcomes you with a large screened-in porch, perfect for enjoying panoramic views of the surrounding natural beauty of the property. Main floor hosts living & family rm, as well as dining, laundry, & kitchen w/ample cabinet space & wood-burning stove. Upstairs, you'll find a sitting w/tiled fireplace & built-cabinets. Master suite offers a gas fireplace, large walk-in closet & en-suite bath. 3 additional bedrooms, & 2 baths complete the 2nd floor. 3rd lvl boasts a multi-functional living space providing versatility, bed & bath, & small kitchenette. Beyond the residence, explore the vast potential of outbuildings and land.

The Sellers have put the time, money and love into making this your perfect Lake Home. Nestled on a large lot with 135ft of frontage on Buffalo Lake. Beautiful views of the lake from both main level and lower level patio doors. 2 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms on main level. Rec room and additional room in basement can be used as den or additional bedroom. Wood burning fireplace for those chilly nights. Attached garage and storage shed for all your storage needs.

A must see 3 bed, 3 bath ranch in the town of Montello! This well-maintained home sits on 2 wooded acres just steps from Lake Montello and Montello City Park. Enjoy the privacy of country living less than a mile from downtown Montello amenities. Inside you'll find vaulted ceilings, a well-appointed kitchen w/ quartz counters and an open stairwell to a spacious, dry, finished basement complete with office, rec room, ample storage and entertaining area. Outside you'll enjoy 2 newer spacious decks, plentiful perennial gardens, fruit trees and a peaceful meandering walking trail. Schedule a showing today! Seller offers buyer a 6-month home warranty. Measurements are approximate, buyer to verify if material.

Here's the getaway property you've been waiting for! Enjoy 150 feet of frontage on Lake Puckaway, and don't forget your water skis! Single Wide Manufactured home is well maintained, and boasts two living areas, as well as 3 bright bedrooms, two full bathrooms AND a den (currently being used as a bedroom). Large kitchen w/ island is perfect for entertaining and has ample storage. All this with conveniences such as washer, dryer, central air and 2 car detached garage! Lot is level for so many uses, and is over an acre. Check out the 3D tour!

This stately 1904 house sits on what was known at the time as Society Hill in Montello, WI. It's waiting for you to provide the time and attention necessary to bring it back to life. The 2,600 square foot house sits on a massive .51 acre double lot and has 5 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. The original section of the home retains most of its original hardwood floors. Since 2021, the electrical service has been upgraded to 200 amps and a new radiant hydronic heating system with an indirect water heater tank has been installed. The most expensive upgrades have been taken care of, and this house is ready to finish to fit your vision.

Unique opportunity awaits: A custom built log home tucked into a private wooded lot and within a short walk to a deeded lake access on 5,000 acre Lake Puckaway. Home offers significant updates beginning with newer roof on home and garage, kitchen countertops, fixtures, appliances and lighting. Open concept living area offers updated laminate wood flooring, a massive wood burning fireplace with an efficient insert that can efficiently heat the home. Knotty pine cathedral ceilings provide a comfortable warm cabin feel. Updated upper level bedroom is spacious and provides room for a guest bedroom or family room area. Main floor bath has new flooring, fixtures & utility space for washer dryer. Outside is a private, shaded landscaped yard visited frequented by deer and turkeys.

Year round living can be enjoyed in this stand alone log home as part of the Oak Ridge Condo Assn on Buffalo Lake. 2 bdrms / 1 bath offering a nice size open concept living, dining and kitchen area. Large deck for outdoor entertaining. Condo Assn offers 400' of water frontage with 4 piers and 1/8 interest in 6 acres of green space. This unit as been well maintained with many updates. Private septic with a shared well that is maintained by the Assn. Act now for your summer time enjoyment with friends and family!

Condo - Year round living can be enjoyed in this stand alone log home as part of the Oak Ridge Condo Assn on Buffalo Lake. 2 bdrms / 1 bath offering a nice size open concept living, dining and kitchen area. Large deck for outdoor entertaining. Condo Assn offers 400' of water frontage with 4 piers and 1/8 interest in 6 acres of green space. This unit as been well maintained with many updates. Private septic with a shared well that is maintained by the Assn. Act now for your summer time enjoyment with friends and family!