Buffalo IN Real Estate & Homes for Sale

If you love river life and are seeking rest and relaxation, this 3 bedroom, 1 bath home is just what you need. Access the nearly new wrap-a-round trex deck by climbing the stairs or use the elevator/lift. Walk a few steps out into your yard to dip your toes in the river while sitting on the concrete seawall or launch your boat, canoe or jet ski in the water at the community public easement or use the shared boat dock just a few steps away. Whatever relaxation looks to you, i am sure you can find it here. Schedule your tour today.

Open Concept 3 bedroom Waterfront property on a Peninsula with floor to ceiling views of water. Canal connects to Tippy River/Upper Lake Shafer. Vaulted knotty pine ceilings with recessed lighting, loft on 2nd level overlooking main level living areas and waterfront. Wrap around deck with waterside roofed structure deckside perfect for a tiki-bar. This newer house has plenty of storage including a raised crawl space, storage under decks, a storage shed. New carpeting in bedrooms, fresh interior paint. Fenced yard, over 200ft. of waterfrontage with multiple areas for piers/docks. Kitchen has an island, views of water. High Eff. Gas furnace. Move-in ready.

DISCOVER LUXURY LIVING IN THIS REMODELED 3 STORY HOME WITH 5 BEDROOMS, 4 BATHS, WITH 2800 SQ.FT. WITH PLENTY OF SPACE FOR COMFORT. ENJOY THE SPACIOUS INTERIOR WITH OPEN CONCEPT, LIVING ROOM WITH GAS FIREPLACE, KITCHEN AND DINING ROOM WITH AMPLE CABINETS,AND ABUNDANCE OF WINDOWS PROVIDING VIEWS OF THE LAKE. THE THIRD FLOOR OFFERS A REC ROOM WITH A WET SINK AND BUILT IN BAR FOR ENTERTAINING. EXTERIOR BOAST A NICELY LANDSCAPE YARD, COVERED PORCH, 5O' LAKE LEVEL WATERFRONT, AND A 16 X 58 DETACHED GARAGE. YOUR DREAM HOME AWAITS!

Updated lake house on Shafer! This adorable home offers a multilevel deck and boat lift to enjoy the lake all season long and a 4 seasons room for the rest of the year. Thislake house boasts 2 spacious bedrooms, large updated kitchen and 1.5 bath, dining area and 2 living spaces. Get ready for lake season!

Updated lake house on Shafer! This adorable home offers a multilevel deck and boat lift to enjoy the lake all season long and a 4 seasons room for the rest of the year. This lake house boasts 2 spacious bedrooms, large updated kitchen and 1.5 bath, dining area and 2 living spaces. Get ready for lake season!

This private oasis is a self-sustained retreat with 3000 linear feet and ~160 acres of waterfront property on Lake Shafer near the quaint town of Monticello. This has everything you can possibly want or need with much, much more. There are 3 magnificent spacious and inviting homes that each sleep over 10, a state-of-the-art barn with a guest suite, an aerated fishing pond stocked with bass. A fishing hut with a full bath and kitchenette covered deck and sleeps 4. If that isn't enough you will find 2 boat houses with automatic lifts, one of which has a party room, kitchen, and powder room. Sandy beach, boat dock, sand volleyball court, fire pit, plumbed grills and decks with picnic benches, kids' jungle gym, outdoor basketball court, indoor basketball court, work out room, fenced grazing pastures, a private bayou, trails, forest, a creek, chicken coop, an orchard, farmland and tranquil open space. Too much to describe!

This private oasis is a self-sustained retreat with 3000 linear feet of waterfront property sitting on 160 private acres on Lake Shafer, forest, trails, ponds and even farmland. You will find two boat houses each equipped with automatic boat lifts which accommodate pontoon boats, jet boats, jet skis and paddle boats. On the water you will also find a sizable pier, sandy beach, beach volleyball court and fire pit. In one boat house there is a party room,??fully functioning kitchen, powder room, a wrap-around partially covered deck that overlooks the water and a BBQ area equipped with gas grills and picnic benches.? The New England style main house greets you with an enormous wrap-around porch. This home was built for comfort and entertaining with 3 bedrooms and sleeping nooks which can easily sleep 12, 4 full baths, one powder room, laundry room, a cathedral ceiling great room, formal dining room, full functioning kitchen with coffee bar plus 2 stone fireplaces and a sizable comfy loft. The stunning guest house has 3 bedrooms, can easily sleep 11, 3 full baths, a great room, full kitchen plus dining area, family room that leads to the deck with a hot tub, plus an outdoor shower.?Want to play a game of basketball, enjoy the full-sized outdoor basketball court.? The impressive barn has six stalls and can house horses, goats and cows easily. The barn has a full bath on the main level, a guest suite in the silo/turret with a living room, kitchenette, bedroom and full bath. Upstairs there is an indoor half-court basketball court and full workout area.?There are fenced in horse pastures surrounded the barn and land as well. The fishing hut sleeps 4 with a kitchenette, full bath and covered deck overlooking the bass stocked aerated pond.?Of course you need a place for the toys, the oversized, newly built shed with heating and cooling can hold those 3 wheelers, motor bikes, snowmobiles, store the boats and collector cars. The newly renovated carriage house is a site to be seen. Set on the South edge of the property, this home overlooks the lake and the bayou with direct access to the water from the tiered cement break wall. This home is an entertainer's dream with sliding door entrances to patios, a fenced in yard. Gorgeous chefs' kitchen, formal and informal dining areas, al fresco dining space outside, a massive great room, 4 built-in sleeping books with lighting, electric and wi-fi, 2 bedrooms, 3 full baths provides ample arrangements for all guests.

This private oasis is a self-sustained retreat with 3000 linear feet of waterfront property sitting on 160 private acres on Lake Shafer, forest, trails, ponds and even farmland. Everything your heart desires and so much more. For those water enthusiasts you will find two boat houses each equipped with automatic boat lifts which accommodate pontoon boats, jet boats, jet skis and paddle boats. On the water you will also find a sizable pier, sandy beach, beach volleyball court and fire pit. In one boat house you will find a party room, fully functioning kitchen, powder room, a wrap-around partially covered deck that overlooks the water and a BBQ area equipped with gas grills and picnic benches. The New England style main house greets you with an enormous wrap-around porch that overlooks the lake. Perfect for dinner after a fun day on the water. This home was built for comfort and entertaining with 3 bedrooms and sleeping nooks which can easily sleep 12, 4 full baths, one powder room, laundry room, a cathedral ceiling great room, formal dining room, full functioning kitchen with coffee bar plus 2 stone fireplaces and a sizable comfy loft. The stunning guest house has 3 bedrooms, can easily sleep 11, 3 full baths, a great room, full kitchen plus dining area, fantastic family room that leads to the deck with a hot tub, plus an outdoor shower. Want to play a game of basketball, enjoy the full-sized outdoor basketball court. The kids can romp around on the jungle gym for hours. The impressive barn has six stalls and can house horses, goats and cows easily. The barn has a full bath on the main level, a guest suite in the silo/turret with a living room, kitchenette, bedroom and full bath. Upstairs there is an indoor half-court basketball court and full workout area. There are fenced in horse pastures surrounded the barn and land as well. The fishing hut sleeps 4 with a kitchenette, full bath and covered deck overlooking the bass stocked aerated pond. Of course you need a place for the toys, the oversized, newly built shed with heating and cooling can hold those 3 wheelers, motor bikes, snowmobiles, store the boats and collector cars. The newly renovated carriage house is a site to be seen. Set on the South edge of the property next to the forest and on the bayou, this home overlooks the lake and the bayou with direct access to the water from the tiered cement break wall. This home is an entertainer's dream with sliding door entrances to patios, a fenced in yard. Gorgeous chefs' kitchen, formal and informal dining areas, al fresco dining space outside, a massive great room with cathedral ceilings, 4 built-in sleeping books with lighting, electric and wi-fi, 2 bedrooms, 3 full baths provides ample arrangements for all guests. This is all set just outside of the quaint little town of Monticello where you will also find Indiana Beach and the amusement park.

PRICE REDUCED!!! Nice home with 3 acres total. Private setting with partial fencing and Tree line. Country View and tillable land within 1/4 mile of Lake Shafer. 30x40 det. garage with storage loft, concrete flooring. Home has nice decks, 6x9 concrete storm shelter. Home has been well maintained and cared for with updates to plumbing, floor coverings, updated appliances. Nice wood burning fireplace for chilly evenings, skylight in main bathroom. Front of house has wood deck/ramp entry, backdoor has aluminum ramp entry. A nice split floor plan. One of the nicest country settings you will find close to Lakes. Asphalt County Road Access.

This massive lakefront home boasts 11 bedrooms and 5 full baths, providing ample space for family and guests. With a detached 4 car tandem garage and 225 feet of waterfront, it offers both luxury and convenience. A boathouse sits at the water's edge, making it easy to enjoy aquatic activities. The property includes its own boat ramp, permanent boat lift with double permanent jetski lift and a relaxing beach area for sunbathing and picnics. Two fully-equipped kitchens ensure that culinary delights are easily prepared. With stunning views and ample amenities, this lakefront retreat is the epitome of lakeside living.

SPRING IS COMING!!! That means summer fun will begin soon. This Lake Shafer home on the Big Monon is ready for you to visit the lake with friends and family. Come take a peek at this 1660 sq ft completely over-hauled lake home. Beautiful Haas cabinets with soft close doors and drawers and plywood boxes, complimented by beautiful quartz countertops in this oversized kitchen with new stainless steel appliances and a skylight to add natural lighting. The whole open concept area is 21x39. The home features all new windows and doors, new roof, siding, mechanicals, kitchen and Bathrooms. Your life should be much easier on the LAKE!

THIS THREE BEDROOM with additional sleeping loft and one bath 1200 SQ FOOT LAKE SHAFER HOME HAS MANY NEWER UPGRADES, GREAT VIEW OF THE LAKE, 20X10 GARAGE, THE LOT HAS SMALL AMOUNT OF MOWING, NEWER UTILITES, WONDERFUL DECKING ON LAKE SIDE. DOUBLE BOAT LIFT WITH A FLOATABLE WAVERUNNER SPOT. NEW FLOORING. COME TAKE A LOOK.

Located just a few hundred meters from main Lake Shafer features stunning views and a spacious yard that is perfect for outdoor activities. With 3 bedrooms and 1 bathroom, this fixer-upper has great potential for those looking to personalize their new home. The house also offers plenty of space with 1400 square feet to work with. Make this house your own and enjoy the tranquility of Bradford Court. Previous inspection available for potential buyers: HOME IS BEING SOLD "AS-IS"

Brand New Furnace!!!! Check out this 2 bedroom 1 bath with 3 additional lots on Keans Creek with 190' of water way easement with access to Lake Shafer. This cottage can be a full time residence or weekend get away with only a 10 minute drive to Indiana Beach! Selling as-is.

Check out this 2 bedroom 1 bath with 3 additional lots on Keans Creek with 190' of water way easement with access to Lake Shafer. This cottage can be a full time residence or weekend get away with only a 10 minute drive to Indiana Beach! Home has brand new furnace and hot water heater. Selling as-is.

Here is your opportunity to own a very private property on the Hoagland Bay and just a couple of minutes from the main lake. This Ranch with walkout basement offers so much. Remodeled master bed and bath, 3 seasons room, a bar, finished garage with heat and a urinal. There is also a wench for lifting heavy objects as well. There are 2 efficiency guest quarters for overflow Total of 650 sq. ft.. 2 Boat lifts are included as well as the waterfront improvements on the deck.

One of the BEST Views on LAKE SHAFER! This 2-unit residence has the potential to become a remarkable 4-unit haven. Enjoy the newly created outdoor oasis, complete with a pergola, inviting inground pool, boat lift, jumping deck, thrilling slide, and convenient jetski dock. Both homes boast a timeless brick exterior, 4 beds, 2 baths, a single 2.5 car garage, gated access, and additional parking. Whether you desire a multifamily retreat or a lucrative investment property, this rare gem, sold as-is, offers an unparalleled experience and one of the most coveted lake views. Don't miss out on this one-of-a-kind opportunity!

Embrace the PINNACLE of LAKESIDE Living with this exceptional property on Lake Shafer. Offering a magnificent view of the lake, this 2-unit residence can be expanded to a possible 4-unit haven. Immerse yourself in the outdoor oasis, featuring a pergola, an inviting inground pool, a new boat lift, a jumping deck, a thrilling lake slide, and a convenient jetski dock. With brick exteriors, both homes provide 4 beds, 2 baths, a single 2.5 car garage, additional parking, and gated access. Whether you desire a multifamily retreat or a smart investment opportunity, this unique property, sold as-is, promises an unparalleled experience and one of the most coveted lake views. Don't let this one-of-a-kind opportunity slip away!

YEAR-ROUND OR VACATION BOUND? Whatever your needs may be, this home offers an array of possibilities! Situated on 2 lots, this 3 bed-2 bath ranch home comes with an adjacent 3rd lot for any expansion or auxiliary buildings needs, plus a 4th lot with 95' of main Lake Shafer frontage to satisfy all of your waterfront recreational desires. Inside you can take in the lake views from the master bedroom, and both the living & family rooms. Original hardwood flooring potentially exists under the carpet in the guest bedrooms & the living room (the latter also features a fireplace and built-ins). "Good bones" abound here, along with a newer roof & central air unit. Laundry room, 2-car attached garage, plenty of closets & storage, PLUS interest in, & use of, the neighborhood common area directly behind house. Be it land or lake, this one has the best of both worlds! *INSPECTIONS WELCOME BUT PROPERTY IS BEING SOLD "AS IS"*

Remodeled 2 bedroom Lake Shafer Home with Views of Amusement Park and Bay View. Finished Loft for additional sleeping space. Excellent location just down the street from Amusement Park South Entrance & Suspension Bridge. Calm Idle Waters with short boat ride to Main Lake. Common Areas allow for a variety of outdoor activities at waterfront. Interior updates include; laminate flooring, drywall walls, trim, updated bathroom and kitchen. Updated utilities include, new heating/cooling unit, spray foam insulation, new wiring, new Plumbing. Exterior has updated windows, vinyl siding, a 7x20 covered porch with views of water, newer wood decking. PWC Dock, Canoe, Paddle Boat can be also purchased with this updated lakehome.

WATERFRONT UPDATED Lake Shafer Home with Boat Dock! Wrap around porch/deck overlooking common area with views of Indiana Beach in the Background!. Excellent location just down the street from the Amusement Park's South Entrance & Suspension Bridge. Aluminum covered lift and composite pier stays with the purchase. Calm Idle Waters with short boat ride to Main Lake. Common Areas allow for a variety outdoor activities at waterfront. Interior updates include; laminate flooring, drywall walls, trim, updated bathroom with tile floors. Remodeled Kitchen includes; raised panel oak cabinets, new appliances, tract lighting. Updated utilities include; new wiring, new Plumbing and A Blink Camera System. Exterior has updated windows, vinyl siding. Den is currently used as a bunkroom for additional sleeping. Plenty of Storage under deck lakeside. Neat and Clean, move right in and enjoy Lake Shafer, Indiana Beach, and all the fun activities that go along with living on the lake OR Rent out home for additional investment income. See posting for adjacent cabin (Unit C) also for sale! Start you Best Summer Now!

2 bedroom 1 bathroom cottage with beautiful pontoon boat by Lake Shafer! This charming cottage has direct access to Lake Shafer with a deeded boat slip. The cottage is offered fully furnished with a new roof and deck as of the fall of 2023, and professionally painted in 2024. The cottage's heat, air conditioning and tankless hot water are all electric and there is no natural gas. The south entrance of Indiana Beach is only a couple minute walk from the cottage. The property is being offered fully furnished and includes 2 boat lifts, dock, 2013 22' Sweetwater pontoon, and 2 Seadoo jetski's (2001 GTX and 2002 GTI). 1 boat lift needs to be lifted back into place and the 2001 GTX needs the motor rebuilt. Commission will be based on the value of the cottage with the furnishings, boat lifts and all watercraft and trailer being sold as personal property. Cottage is part of a PUD and each owner has access to all of the common areas.

Lake Level on Main Lake Shafer, best views of Indiana Beach Amusement Park. This 3,284 SF. 2 story has multiple boat lifts & waverunner Ramp, Covered lakeside porch with pull down blinds. Remodeled kitchen with subway tile backsplashes, solid surface counters, soft close cabinets. Main Level is Open Concept w/Lake views. Brick gas fireplace in Dining Area, new plank/tile flooring on main level, Remodeled full bath off Kitchen/dining area. Utilities have been updated with zoned heating/cooling, Reverse Osmosis Drinking System, Unfin. partial basement/crawl perfect for storage. Upper level bedrooms have private balcony/sitting areas lakeside. Main Bedroom has a powder room with built-in cabinetry. Guest bedroom/game room over att. garage has private stairway down to a 2 car+ garage with high ceilings for additional storage and a sink also included in garage. Exterior upgrades include; new gutter guards, security system, new electric to boatlift, a firepit lakeside. Brick Exterior for minimal exterior maintenance. Den on main level has closet and full bath which could be utilized as a 4th Bedroom. New Wood on Lakeside Walkways and Wave Runner Lifts.

One story home on almost a full acre of land in the country, offering the perfect blend of tranquility and convenience. This 3 bedroom, 2 full bath has a spacious master bedroom en-suite with a walk-in closet and a large bathroom with both a tub and stand alone shower. There is plenty of room to enjoy the expansive yard and many possibilities for outdoor enjoyment. Although some updates could enhance the overall appeal of the home, its proximity to Indiana Beach, shopping and dining make it an ideal location for those seeking a peaceful retreat just minutes away from downtown Monticello.

Discover lakeside luxury in this completely remodeled 3-bed, 2-bath, 1776 sq. ft. Lake Shafer Home. Enjoy 98 feet of frontage on over an acre of land stocked with a 32 x 24 pole barn. Revel in the upgraded kitchen, expanded bedrooms, and a new walk-in closet in the primary suite. Quartz countertops, new flooring, paint, light fixtures, appliances, windows, doors and trim create a fresh, modern feel. The main floor bathroom features a new tiled walk in shower and heated jet soaking tub. With a fully finished walkout basement, this lake home offers the perfect blend of comfort and style. Welcome to your lakeside retreat.