15 West Neck Road
Shelter Island, NY 11964

TWO HEARTHS: STUNNING GREEK REVIVAL~ SHELTER ISLAND Discover your slice of perfectly preserved paradise on Shelter Island, with ample room for expansion and add your own brand-new pool. This impeccably preserved architectural masterpiece dates back to 1848 and stands as one of the four original Greek Revival homes on Shelter Island. Truly an unparalleled treasure. The appeal is instantly clear with charming colonial styling on the columned, wraparound porch. The interiors are well-equipped for luxury living and can easily be updated to accommodate many design possibilities. This intact residence, which boasts 3 bedrooms and 3 baths, sits on a generous 1.7-acre parcel in coveted C zone, offering boundless opportunities for expansion and enhancement. With period-accurate trim detailing, the existing structure lends itself beautifully to transformation. It leaves ample space for a potential guest house while still allowing for substantial upgrades, including the addition of a pool to the expansive backyard. Positioned against sprawling parcels, this property enjoys both privacy and proximity. Moments away, discover the allure of Sunset Beach Resort, the prestigious Shelter Island Country Club & Golf Course, The Perlman Music Program, The Pridwin Hotel & Cottages, and The Heights, ensuring a lifestyle enriched with leisure and culture. Best of all locations to be moments to Sag Harbor/Hamptons and/or the North Fork. Less than 2 miles to the South Ferry and 1.2 miles to the North Ferry. Don't miss your chance to own a piece of Shelter Island's history. Embrace the opportunity to craft your dream oasis in this unparalleled setting on the East End. C0-Exclusive: $1,999,999.