Fair Harbor NY Real Estate & Homes for Sale

PRICED TO SELL... Nestled on the serene and highly coveted Ocean Beach of Fire Island, New York, 85 Bungalow Walk presents a rare opportunity to own an oceanfront gem. This exceptional property boasts breathtaking ocean views from nearly every room, offering a unique chance to immerse oneself in the tranquil beauty of the seaside from the comfort of home. With three bedrooms, two bathrooms, and two expansive decks, this residence combines comfort with the luxury of oceanfront living. The rarity of such a find in Ocean Beach, known for its limited availability of oceanfront properties, makes this offering a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to secure your own slice of paradise.

Perfectly positioned in the highly coveted town of Ocean Beach, moments from the beach and town center, This four bedroom, three bathroom home has been owned and cared for by the same family for 50 years. Recently renovated for summertime enjoyment, the main level of this split-level home features an expansive, bright, and airy great room, allowing for comfortable living and entertaining. The windowed open kitchen with new stainless steel appliances flows into the ample dining area. Through sliding doors, a large back deck extends the entertaining space, boasting an outdoor shower and a storage shed with a washer/dryer. A first-floor bedroom is generous in scale, and the full bathroom makes this a perfect spot for guests. Completing this level is the front porch, ideal for enjoying morning coffee or an evening cocktail in the ocean breeze. Upstairs, the primary bedroom features a renovated ensuite bath, an oversized closet, and a balcony. The two secondary bedrooms are sun-filled, and the third updated bathroom is on this floor. Additional features of this special home include high ceilings and ample storage throughout, as well as a split system A/C. This home is ready for Summer fun!

Perfectly positioned in the highly coveted town of Ocean Beach, moments from the beach and town center, This four bedroom, three bathroom home has been owned and cared for by the same family for 50 years. Recently renovated for summertime enjoyment, the main level of this split-level home features an expansive, bright, and airy great room, allowing for comfortable living and entertaining. The windowed open kitchen with new stainless steel appliances flows into the ample dining area. Through sliding doors, a large back deck extends the entertaining space, boasting an outdoor shower and a storage shed with a washer/dryer. A first-floor bedroom is generous in scale, and the full bathroom makes this a perfect spot for guests. Completing this level is the front porch, ideal for enjoying morning coffee or an evening cocktail in the ocean breeze. Upstairs, the primary bedroom features a renovated ensuite bath, an oversized closet, and a balcony. The two secondary bedrooms are sun-filled, and the third updated bathroom is on this floor. Additional features of this special home include high ceilings and ample storage throughout, as well as a split system A/C. This home is ready for Summer fun!

Bring your toothbrush...and sunscreen, as an extraordinary opportunity awaits you - the chance to own not one, but TWO beachblock houses. Relax by the heated pool and hot tub while immersing yourself in the beauty of Fire Island, leaving cars and worries behind. Whether you're seeking exciting moments or tranquil solitude, The Mooring beckons. This renovated 2-house retreat, consisting of both the main and guest houses oozing charm, is a mere three doors away from the beach in Ocean Bay Park. Perfect for up to 12 people, these homes provide an ideal blend of togetherness and privacy. Enjoy the luxury of a FULL-SIZED (16x32) heated pool and a hot tub, offering the ultimate relaxation and rejuvenation. The main house features 4 bedrooms and 1.5 baths, while the cottage provides 2 bedrooms and 1.5 baths - all situated on one of the largest lots available on Fire Island. This is your ticket to a serene and spacious haven where unforgettable memories are made. Owner financing available.

Bring your toothbrush...and sunscreen, as an extraordinary opportunity awaits you - the chance to own not one, but TWO beachblock houses. Relax by the heated pool and hot tub while immersing yourself in the beauty of Fire Island, leaving cars and worries behind. Whether you're seeking exciting moments or tranquil solitude, The Mooring beckons. This renovated 2-house retreat, consisting of both the main and guest houses oozing charm, is a mere three doors away from the beach in Ocean Bay Park. Perfect for up to 12 people, these homes provide an ideal blend of togetherness and privacy. Enjoy the luxury of a FULL-SIZED (16x32) heated pool and a hot tub, offering the ultimate relaxation and rejuvenation. The main house features 4 bedrooms and 1.5 baths, while the cottage provides 2 bedrooms and 1.5 baths - all situated on one of the largest lots available on Fire Island. This is your ticket to a serene and spacious haven where unforgettable memories are made. Owner financing available.

This stunning, fully furnished home was newly constructed in 2022 and is situated on the northeast side of the street between the Bay and the Ocean. Boasting Andersen windows, mahogany decking, and low-maintenance siding, this elevated home offers modern comfort and convenience. Inside, step into the main foyer which leads to the first guest room with an en-suite bathroom. The laundry room, equipped with built-in cabinetry and shelving, features two washers and two dryers. The second guest bedroom doubles as a home gym and features an en-suite bathroom as well. The main floor great room combines a spacious living area, dining area, and gourmet kitchen with high ceilings and oversized windows for ample lighting and privacy. The kitchen includes an ample sized island with sink and drinking water filtration system, complemented by top-of-the-line appliances including a propane stove/oven and built-in stainless steel Bosch microwave. Located on the second floor, you will find the primary bedroom with a walk-in closet and an en-suite bathroom featuring double sinks, a water closet, and a luxurious soaking bathtub nestled within a walk-in shower. Step out onto the private west-facing balcony to enjoy breathtaking bay views. Adjacent to the primary bedroom is a guest room with its own balcony, offering serene bay views, a spacious closet. Completing this level, a hall bathroom features double sinks and a shower bath. Ascend up a half-staircase to encounter a versatile guest room/office with ample closet space and east exposure. Relax in the screened-in porch, offering tranquil pool views and northeast exposure, thoughtfully furnished for your comfort. Venture up to the expansive roof deck where you will indulge in the breathtaking panoramic ocean and bay views offering 360 degree vistas with spectacular sunsets. This rooftop retreat is perfect for entertaining or unwinding in style. The pool deck beckons with a heated saltwater swimming pool, wet bar, ice machine, Sedona barbecue, outdoor shower, and lounge area. This home is a true sanctuary of modern living and coastal charm, offering luxury, convenience, and breathtaking views.

This stunning, fully furnished home was newly constructed in 2022 and is situated on the northeast side of the street between the Bay and the Ocean. Boasting Andersen windows, mahogany decking, and low-maintenance siding, this elevated home offers modern comfort and convenience. Inside, step into the main foyer which leads to the first guest room with an en-suite bathroom. The laundry room, equipped with built-in cabinetry and shelving, features two washers and two dryers. The second guest bedroom doubles as a home gym and features an en-suite bathroom as well. The main floor great room combines a spacious living area, dining area, and gourmet kitchen with high ceilings and oversized windows for ample lighting and privacy. The kitchen includes an ample sized island with sink and drinking water filtration system, complemented by top-of-the-line appliances including a propane stove/oven and built-in stainless steel Bosch microwave. Located on the second floor, you will find the primary bedroom with a walk-in closet and an en-suite bathroom featuring double sinks, a water closet, and a luxurious soaking bathtub nestled within a walk-in shower. Step out onto the private west-facing balcony to enjoy breathtaking bay views. Adjacent to the primary bedroom is a guest room with its own balcony, offering serene bay views, a spacious closet. Completing this level, a hall bathroom features double sinks and a shower bath. Ascend up a half-staircase to encounter a versatile guest room/office with ample closet space and east exposure. Relax in the screened-in porch, offering tranquil pool views and northeast exposure, thoughtfully furnished for your comfort. Venture up to the expansive roof deck where you will indulge in the breathtaking panoramic ocean and bay views offering 360 degree vistas with spectacular sunsets. This rooftop retreat is perfect for entertaining or unwinding in style. The pool deck beckons with a heated saltwater swimming pool, wet bar, ice machine, Sedona barbecue, outdoor shower, and lounge area. This home is a true sanctuary of modern living and coastal charm, offering luxury, convenience, and breathtaking views.

Charming West End cottage just 3 houses off the beach in the lovely West End section of Cherry Grove. Hardwood floors, open kitchen/living room. Beautiful pool and deck surround with plenty of room for gardens! Central heat and air-conditioning. Outdoor shower, too!

Charming West End cottage just 3 houses off the beach in the lovely West End section of Cherry Grove. Hardwood floors, open kitchen/living room. Beautiful pool and deck surround with plenty of room for gardens! Central heat and air-conditioning. Outdoor shower, too!

Captivating and expansive 6700 sqft. Colonial nestled in "The Moorings," offering a resort-like backyard oasis and tranquil water marina. This distinguished residence resides within a private community featuring a 24-hour guard house. Step into a dramatic 20' Grand Entrance Foyer that sets the tone for the elegance within, boasting 5 bedrooms and 5.5 baths. Discover exquisite details like Coffered Ceilings and Extensive Mahogany Trim throughout. The Master Wing, complete with a Balcony, overlooks the stunning Private Yard featuring a Pool and Pool House-a paradise for hosting and relaxation. The expansive Gourmet Kitchen with Heated Floors is a chef's dream. Residents enjoy access to the community Marina and Tennis Courts. This remarkable property is being sold as is, currently occupied, offering a rare opportunity to be a part of this private gated community.

Captivating and expansive 6700 sqft. Colonial nestled in "The Moorings," offering a resort-like backyard oasis and tranquil water marina. This distinguished residence resides within a private community featuring a 24-hour guard house. Step into a dramatic 20' Grand Entrance Foyer that sets the tone for the elegance within, boasting 5 bedrooms and 5.5 baths. Discover exquisite details like Coffered Ceilings and Extensive Mahogany Trim throughout. The Master Wing, complete with a Balcony, overlooks the stunning Private Yard featuring a Pool and Pool House-a paradise for hosting and relaxation. The expansive Gourmet Kitchen with Heated Floors is a chef's dream. Residents enjoy access to the community Marina and Tennis Courts. This remarkable property is being sold as is, currently occupied, offering a rare opportunity to be a part of this private gated community.

Magnificent 2-story contemporary right on the Atlantic Ocean! Four wonderful bedrooms - including two en-suite masters and two more guest bathrooms. New open kitchen/living floor plan with hardwood floors, two fireplaces. This home pays attention to all the details - And nothing beats the view from the decks!

Magnificent 2-story contemporary right on the Atlantic Ocean! Four wonderful bedrooms - including two en-suite masters and two more guest bathrooms. New open kitchen/living floor plan with hardwood floors, two fireplaces. This home pays attention to all the details - And nothing beats the view from the decks!

Stunning 5BR Ranch on acre+ property-Updated, Immaculate Sprawling Ranch with Designer Kitchen and Baths-Bright 7 Skylights and Airy with beautiful stone dual fireplace-Layout is interchangeable-Beautiful Yard, IGP, Pavilion-Lovely! Home has 2.5 oversized Garage.

Stunning 5BR Ranch on acre+ property-Updated, Immaculate Sprawling Ranch with Designer Kitchen and Baths-Bright 7 Skylights and Airy with beautiful stone dual fireplace-Layout is interchangeable-Beautiful Yard, IGP, Pavilion-Lovely! Home has 2.5 oversized Garage.

Classic Cherry Grove Cottage with a large kitchen, cathedral ceilings and great location! 3 bedrooms, including first floor bedroom and two more bedrooms on second floor! Rear deck with utility shed and outdoor shower.

Classic Cherry Grove Cottage with a large kitchen, cathedral ceilings and great location! 3 bedrooms, including first floor bedroom and two more bedrooms on second floor! Rear deck with utility shed and outdoor shower.

This lovely 2-bedroom cottage with wonderful guest cabana is located one house off the beach! The 12 X 26 pool gets sun all day long and has great outdoor space for entertaining! The cottage has an updated galley kitchen with service window to the outdoor dinning deck, bright master bedroom and second guest room. The over-sized cabana sports a four-poster bed and full bath & sitting area. Outdoor shower, too!

This lovely 2-bedroom cottage with wonderful guest cabana is located one house off the beach! The 12 X 26 pool gets sun all day long and has great outdoor space for entertaining! The cottage has an updated galley kitchen with service window to the outdoor dinning deck, bright master bedroom and second guest room. The over-sized cabana sports a four-poster bed and full bath & sitting area. Outdoor shower, too!

A unique opportunity to purchase a "NEW" fully renovated 1940's cottage with a large, oasis-like private yard. Perched mid-block on one of the highest points in Cherry Grove, every inch of this charming 2 bedroom, 1 bath home was reimagined and rebuilt in 2018. Fully legal, renovations include: modern kitchen w/high-end appliances, gorgeous marble bathroom, fully insulated, NEST controlled central heat and air-conditioning, new doors and windows, new septic system, new plumbing with On-Demand hot water. New electric, plus new fencing, decking and roof. Outside, enjoy a new heated salt-water pool, outdoor kitchen w/sink, storage & grill, large outdoor shower and multiple seating and dining areas designed for alfresco living. Poolside Storage Cabana has Miele washer and dryer, custom storage and 2nd refrigerator. Select furniture available for purchase/negotiation. MLS# 3467150

A unique opportunity to purchase a "NEW" fully renovated 1940's cottage with a large, oasis-like private yard. Perched mid-block on one of the highest points in Cherry Grove, every inch of this charming 2 bedroom, 1 bath home was reimagined and rebuilt in 2018. Fully legal, renovations include: modern kitchen w/high-end appliances, gorgeous marble bathroom, fully insulated, NEST controlled central heat and air-conditioning, new doors and windows, new septic system, new plumbing with On-Demand hot water. New electric, plus new fencing, decking and roof. Outside, enjoy a new heated salt-water pool, outdoor kitchen w/sink, storage & grill, large outdoor shower and multiple seating and dining areas designed for alfresco living. Poolside Storage Cabana has Miele washer and dryer, custom storage and 2nd refrigerator. Select furniture available for purchase/negotiation. MLS# 3467150

Spectacular oceanfront compound featuring 4 units (2 bed/2ba primary; 4 bed/1ba rental; studio rental; 1 bed detached cottage rental). Plus basic plans for a proposed 3rd floor addition for 2 new bed 2ba unit. This double lot has its own private beach access and large deck overlooking the dunes, white sandy beach and Atlantic Ocean. 1/4 mile to Cherry Grove dock; 1 mile to Pines. Very private and quiet. There is great potential to renovate the kitchens and baths to increase seasonal rental rates. NOW AVAILABLE for SEASONAL RENTAL - Three Units from $20K, $22K & $30K per month for June, July & August. Weekly rentals will be considered. CALL MITCH NOW TO SCHEDULE A SHOWING!

Spectacular oceanfront compound featuring 4 units (2 bed/2ba primary; 4 bed/1ba rental; studio rental; 1 bed detached cottage rental). Plus basic plans for a proposed 3rd floor addition for 2 new bed 2ba unit. This double lot has its own private beach access and large deck overlooking the dunes, white sandy beach and Atlantic Ocean. 1/4 mile to Cherry Grove dock; 1 mile to Pines. Very private and quiet. There is great potential to renovate the kitchens and baths to increase seasonal rental rates. NOW AVAILABLE for SEASONAL RENTAL - Three Units from $20K, $22K & $30K per month for June, July & August. Weekly rentals will be considered. CALL MITCH NOW TO SCHEDULE A SHOWING!