Monticello IN Real Estate & Homes for Sale

Welcome to your dream home in Stahls Colonial Oaks subdivision! This upgraded 3-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom haven offers the perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and charm. Nestled in a serene neighborhood, this spacious abode boasts over 1700 square feet of meticulously designed living space. Step inside and be greeted by an inviting atmosphere filled with natural light and modern finishes. The heart of the home is the well-appointed kitchen, complete with sleek countertops and ample storage space. Entertain guests effortlessly in the adjacent dining area, or unwind in the cozy living room. Retreat to the luxurious master suite or two additional bedrooms that provide plenty of space for family or guests. Step outside to discover your own private oasis. Enjoy summer barbecues on the expansive deck or roast marshmallows around the fire pit. A covered porch with a porch swing offers the ideal spot for morning coffee or evening stargazing. Boat enthusiasts will delight in the easy access to Lake Freeman via a nearby easement. This home also features an attached 2-car garage, parking is always a breeze. Conveniently located just a short walk from Lake Freeman, this home offers endless opportunities for outdoor recreation. Whether you're boating, fishing, or simply soaking in the natural beauty, you'll love calling this place home. Don't miss your chance to own this exquisite property - schedule your showing today and experience the best of lakeside living in Stahls Colonial Oaks!

PERFECTLY PLANNED! This 3-4 bedroom / 2 bath ranch home is 'just right' with it's open living space & friendly floor plan that flows from the kitchen, through the dining area & into the living room, which features a cheery fireplace, vaulted ceilings, & display alcoves. The additional private den serves multiple needs: 4th bedroom, office, game room, & more. Nice-sized master bedroom with a spacious, updated master bathroom w/soaking tub & shower. Various updates throughout including: lighting, flooring, painted trim/doors/cabinets, newer water heater & fridge, just to name a few. Situated on a corner lot in a newer, nicer subdivision, you'll also love the inviting back patio: private, spacious, & perfectly placed off of the kitchen & dining spaces for easy entertainment & functions. Shed with overhead door and electric an added perk. *CONTINGENT ON SELLERS FINDING SUITABLE HOUSING IN 16 DAYS*

Wow factor is definitely here! Newly rennovated and bunk house added for addiitonal sleeping, comes fully furnished so turn key ready for your summer fun or AirBNB investment. Permanent electric boat lift, huge incredible deck, covered porch area, spectacular views, quick easy access to the main lake and only 6 min to Indiana Beach, walking distance night clubs and eateries...great location for peaceful and scenic relaxation but quick boat ride for awesome lake fun! Close to .3 acres for spacious yard area. Sweet sweet place!

All brick 1 story home setting on nearly 3 quarters of an acre. Open concept floor plan with 2/3 bedrooms, 2 baths, 1920 sqft , and fireplace. Large partially covered concrete patio overlooking the backyard. 24x24 all brick insulated garage. Plumbing system did not hold pressure.

A perfect set up for lake living! Setting on 2 lake level lots with 100 ft of frontage that includes a steel sea wall, docks and a permanent covered electric boat lift. Step inside to a brand new kitchen with granite counter tops and a tile back splash. An open concept floor plan is ideal for entertaining. The living room features cathedral ceilings, a stone fireplace and a sliding glass door that leads out to the lakeside deck. Inside offers 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, a master suite with a walk in closet and 2 main floor bedrooms. Ample storage offered from the 2 car garage and the 1 car garage. A beautiful lake level lot and an charming updated lake home. Lake life awaits!!

3 Bedroom 1 Bath home located less than a mile from Norway Dam. A new private well was just dug for this home.

This private oasis is a self-sustained retreat with 3000 linear feet of waterfront property sitting on 160 private acres on Lake Shafer, forest, trails, ponds and even farmland. You will find two boat houses each equipped with automatic boat lifts which accommodate pontoon boats, jet boats, jet skis and paddle boats. On the water you will also find a sizable pier, sandy beach, beach volleyball court and fire pit. In one boat house there is a party room,??fully functioning kitchen, powder room, a wrap-around partially covered deck that overlooks the water and a BBQ area equipped with gas grills and picnic benches.? The New England style main house greets you with an enormous wrap-around porch. This home was built for comfort and entertaining with 3 bedrooms and sleeping nooks which can easily sleep 12, 4 full baths, one powder room, laundry room, a cathedral ceiling great room, formal dining room, full functioning kitchen with coffee bar plus 2 stone fireplaces and a sizable comfy loft. The stunning guest house has 3 bedrooms, can easily sleep 11, 3 full baths, a great room, full kitchen plus dining area, family room that leads to the deck with a hot tub, plus an outdoor shower.?Want to play a game of basketball, enjoy the full-sized outdoor basketball court.? The impressive barn has six stalls and can house horses, goats and cows easily. The barn has a full bath on the main level, a guest suite in the silo/turret with a living room, kitchenette, bedroom and full bath. Upstairs there is an indoor half-court basketball court and full workout area.?There are fenced in horse pastures surrounded the barn and land as well. The fishing hut sleeps 4 with a kitchenette, full bath and covered deck overlooking the bass stocked aerated pond.?Of course you need a place for the toys, the oversized, newly built shed with heating and cooling can hold those 3 wheelers, motor bikes, snowmobiles, store the boats and collector cars. The newly renovated carriage house is a site to be seen. Set on the South edge of the property, this home overlooks the lake and the bayou with direct access to the water from the tiered cement break wall. This home is an entertainer's dream with sliding door entrances to patios, a fenced in yard. Gorgeous chefs' kitchen, formal and informal dining areas, al fresco dining space outside, a massive great room, 4 built-in sleeping books with lighting, electric and wi-fi, 2 bedrooms, 3 full baths provides ample arrangements for all guests.

Located south of Monticello and just a short drive to Lafayette/W. Lafayette, this well built and meticulously renovated 1967 all-brick home, offering a harmonious blend of classic charm and modern comfort. Located on nearly a half acre and close to the Lake Freeman Sail Club, this gem grants access to Lake Freeman through its private boat ramp. Admire the breathtaking lake views from the expansive 20 x 46 all-composite deck, an idyllic spot for morning coffee or evening soirees. Entertain with ease in the newly appointed kitchen, boasting gleaming appliances and stylish finishes. Luxuriate in the ambiance of the meticulously updated interiors, where new flooring, windows, and doors enhance the allure of each room. Two tastefully renovated bathrooms and 3 adequate sized bedrooms. A two-car garage adds convenience, while the open concept layout ensures ample space for daily living and entertaining alike. Whether relishing the serenity of living near the lake or indulging in outdoor adventures, this low maintenance updated home will allow you time to pursue your desires. Schedule your showing today!

Beautiful Updated Brick Ranch with a rural setting and heated/part finished 32x56 Pole building. This 3 bed/2 bath home has vaulted living area ceilings with a brick/gas fireplace as a centerpiece. Interior finish includes; solid panel doors, stained wood trim, skylights for natural lighting, main bath has a new granite vanity. Kitchen has tiled backsplashes and new appliances. Pole Barn has a combination of heated flooring and radiant ceiling heat, a 24x32 loft with exterior deck/landing, a fully functional bathroom. Huge Backyard Deck with Fenced Yard, covered front porch. Immaculately kept house with recent interior and exterior updates.

Truly one of a Kind! Discover the epitome of lakeside living on Lake Shafer! ONE Of the BEST VIEWS on the LAKE! This remarkable ONE of a KIND Lakefront property features a inground pool, water slide, jetski dock, and pier, along with 4 beds, 2 baths, a brick exterior, and gated entrance. But that's not all! There's a separate sister property available for purchase, offering the same gated entrance, pergola, garage, boat lift, and a thrilling jumping deck into the lake. Perfect for a multifamily lake retreat, these properties provide the ultimate combination of luxury, recreation, and relaxation. Don't miss your chance to own this extraordinary lakeside haven and create memories that will last a lifetime! SOLD AS-IS

Truly one of a KIND! Experience lakeside luxury at its finest on Lake Shafer! This stunning lakefront property offers a pergola, new deck, boat lift, dock, 4 beds, 2 baths, brick exterior, gated entrance, and a 2-car garage. But that's not all! Adjacent to it, a separate sister property is available for purchase, behind the same gated entrance, an inviting inground pool, a jetski dock, and an exhilarating water slide leading straight into the lake. The perfect setting for a multifamily lake retreat. Don't miss this incredible opportunity to own both properties and create your own lakeside paradise! Sold AS-IS

Experience lakeside luxury at its finest on Lake Shafer! This stunning lakefront property offers a pergola, new deck, boat lift, dock, 4 beds, 2 baths, brick exterior, gated entrance, and a 2-car garage. But that's not all! Adjacent to it, a separate sister property is available for purchase, behind the same gated entrance, an inviting inground pool, a jetski dock, and an exhilarating water slide leading straight into the lake. The perfect setting for a multifamily lake retreat. Don't miss this incredible opportunity to own one OR both properties and create your own lakeside paradise! Sold AS-IS

Discover the epitome of lakeside living on Lake Shafer! ONE Of the BEST VIEWS on the LAKE! This remarkable ONE of a KIND Lakefront property features a inground pool, water slide, jetski dock, and pier, along with 4 beds, 2 baths, a brick exterior, and gated entrance. But that's not all! There's a separate sister property available for purchase, offering the same gated entrance, pergola, garage, boat lift, and a thrilling jumping deck into the lake. Perfect for a multifamily lake retreat, these properties provide the ultimate combination of luxury, recreation, and relaxation. Don't miss your chance to own this extraordinary lakeside haven and create memories that will last a lifetime! SOLD AS-IS

Natural park like beauty with 2 gorgeous ponds, Lake Freeman access with boat lift and 106' of canal frontage, 5 incredible ACRES!! Easy walking trails throughout and stunning views! Home boasts two outstanding kitchens, two great living areas perfect for combined families, sun room overlooking pond, 3 separate storage barns. Home comes completely furnished if desired.

Welcome to your very own Lake Shafer Paradise! Imagine a beautifully updated home right on the water, where you can see the lake sparkle every day! This property is not just one home, but two!! Yes, it has a separate guest house where others can stay or use it as a hang out space at night/rainy days. Both places have new interior layouts, to better suit lake life, on top of a more modern style. New windows & doors, which not only look nice but also help keep the house warm in winter and cool in summer. The mechanicals are also brand new, piece of mind you won't have to worry about replacing those things. Plus, there's a new Private well installed on the property, plumbing added to the guest house, allowing for the convenience of a bathroom and kitchenette. Ample parking here and still so much potential for the outdoor space to be made your own! Temporary boat lift is here, but plenty of space to put in a permanent lift/deck once you move in. This lake house is situated in a cozy spot - a perfect place to entertain, relax, have a fire and enjoy your new water views. It's like having a fun vacation spot...but it's all yours to enjoy any time you want! Don't miss the opportunity to own this slice of paradise!

Charming 3-bedroom home, with much to offer including soaring ceilings, warmth and natural light. Spacious kitchen with newer stainless steel gas range, hood fan, and refrigerator. Front and back covered porches provide space to unwind outdoors. This home offers plenty of storage inside and out. A spacious 18x24 barn provides covered parking, with four additional parking spaces off the alley. Renovated in 2016, with recent updates adding to it's appeal including new windows, gutters, interior doors, vinyl flooring, and a refreshed shower surround. Conveniently located just a couple of blocks from downtown, walkable to nearby banks, restaurants, downtown events, and stores! Inspections are welcome, but this gem is sold as-is.

Welcome to your very own Lake Shafer Paradise! Imagine a beautifully updated home right on the water, where you can see the lake sparkle every day! This property is not just one home, but two!! Yes, it has a separate guest house where others can stay or use it as a hang out space at night/rainy days. Both places have new interior layouts, to better suit lake life, on top of a more modern style. New windows and doors, which not only look nice but also help keep the house warm in winter and cool in summer. The mechanicals are also brand new, piece of mind you won't have to worry about replacing those things. Plus, there's a new Private well installed on the property, plumbing added to the guest house, allowing for the convenience of a bathroom and kitchenette. Ample parking here and still so much potential for the outdoor space to be made your own! Temporary boat lift is here, but plenty of space to put in a permanent lift/deck once you move in.This lake house is situated in a cozy spot - a perfect place to entertain, relax, have a fire and enjoy your new water views. It's like having a fun vacation spot, but all yours to enjoy any time you want! Don't miss the opportunity to own this slice of paradise!

WELCOME HOME! This STUNNING ranch on LARGE LOT offers a blend of luxury and leisure, perfect for those seeking a comfortable lifestyle. You will be amazed with the open floor plan and abundant sunlight of this BEAUTY! There are so many desirable features that make this home really stand out!...Vaulted ceilings, Cozy Fireplace, Arched and Inviting Entry, Beautiful Wood Floors, BRAND NEW High End Bosch Appliances, GE profile Washer/Dryer unit, Walk-In Pantry, Deluxe Primary Suite with HUGE Closet Area and Two more Spacious Bedrooms with large closets. The Daylight Basement adds versatility to the property, providing additional living space, sleep space, or room for customization to fit your needs. Step outside to discover your own private oasis, featuring sprawling landscapes, covered patio and a fenced in back yard. The Oversized 3 Car Garage with a NEW HEAT AND AIR CONDITIONING unit and FRESH EPOXY FLOORS is also a great extension for many other uses. There is an On site generator plus a Bonus Outdoor Shed! Situated in a desireable location, this home offers convenience and serenity, providing the ideal balance of seclusion and accessibility!

Welcome to a beautifully redone home in Monticello! This 4 bedroom house features new galore including a complete rewire, hvac system, all new kitchen and baths, and list keeps going. The new blends well with the historic charm! Come see for yourself today!

Live Here Year Round or use as a Summer/Weekend Getaway. This 3 Bedroom, 2 Bath Mobile is ready for a new owner. Only minutes from Lake Schaefer. Lots of things to do and see in this area. Don't let this chance pass you by to find an affordable home in the area. Furnace and A/C are 3 years old. Roof and Siding 5 years old.

Welcome to your dream retreat on the shores of beautiful Lake Freeman! This newly completed property offers the perfect blend of modern luxury and serene lakeside living. With its breathtaking view of the lake, this home is a haven for nature enthusiasts and those seeking tranquility. Imagine waking up to the shimmering waters of Lake Freeman right outside your window. Inside, you'll find three spacious bedrooms, each boasting its private full bath, ensuring privacy and comfort for you and your guests. The master suite offers a peaceful escape with stunning lake views to start and end your day. The kitchen is a culinary enthusiast's dream, featuring massive concrete countertops that provide ample workspace and a sleek, contemporary aesthetic. The rich wood floors throughout the home add warmth and character to the open living spaces. Step outside to the overhanging deck on the lakeside, where you can relax, entertain, and soak in the spectacular views. Whether it's morning coffee, sunset cocktails, or stargazing nights, this deck is the perfect spot to enjoy it all. Currently being rented on a day-to-day basis, this property is a fantastic investment opportunity and is being sold turnkey. This means you can start enjoying the lake life right away or continue to generate income from this stunning lakeside retreat. Don't miss your chance to own a piece of paradise on Lake Freeman. Schedule a viewing today and experience the beauty and serenity that this property has to offer. Your dream lakefront lifestyle awaits!

Welcome to this cute and cozy 2BR, 1.5B home in Monticello. Updated roof in 2021, new vinyl windows in 2013. Move-in Ready with fresh interior paint. interior updates in 2013 include new electrical wiring, added insulation, drywall walls, updated plumbing, floors. Furnace and Central A/C were also updated 2018. All appliances stay with purchase. Additional Storage available with an 8X12 storage shed.

Welcome to 3852 Forest Lodge Loop, an entertainment paradise, beautifully situated revealing some of the best views on Lake Shafer. Perfectly positioned within the highly coveted, quiet, and peaceful Big Monon Bay, only seconds away from the all sports main lake. You're met with picturesque all new renewable Anderson windows as you enter the home, other interior features include updated bathrooms, dual fireplace, wood accents, custom carpentry, built-in storage, newer mechanicals, and a formal dining room overlooking the lake. Important exterior features include multi-level decking, permanent double boat house w/ party deck, 58' of prime water frontage, garden pond, fireplace, and 24x24 garage. Noteworthy details include an abundance of wildlife, breathtaking sunrise and sunsets, ideal fishing, ample parking space, and a no-wake zone that makes relaxing and swimming enjoyable. This secluded estate allows for a perfect blend of every type of lake life living. Loved and maintained within the same family for nearly 30 years, a once in a lifetime opportunity has come for the next lucky owners to call this their serenity. Can be sold turn-key! Must see to appreciate, too many details to list, call for more!

A lovely 3 bedroom, 2 bath, 2 story on the south side of Monticello. Centrally located a few blocks away the high school, hospital, and the city park with street and alley access. Original character with hardwood floors, a wood burning fireplace, and an enclosed porch which could be converted to additional living space. Carport, newly painted deck, full basement, and asphalt driveway with detached garage are just more reasons to be the new owner of this cozy home.

Private setting wide Lake Freeman Views with 90' Lake Frontage. Remodeled 3 bed/2.5 bath ranch style with an additional 2 bed/1 bath guest house for guests /large gatherings. Extensive lakeside improvements include; 3 bay lift system with covered composite decking, steel seawall, gazebo/bar on lakeside 30x32 deck. Multi-Level paver patios lakeside with firepit, outdoor kitchen. Main house custom finishes include; kitchen with raised panel cabinetry/crown molding, quartz counters and kitchen island, Mood lighting, stainless kitchen sink. Open Living Spaces include vaulted ceiling with recessed lights on dimmers, custom masonry gas fireplace, partitioned off den/office area lakeside. Main bath has marble flooring/walls, quartz vanity. Plenty of open space lakeside with covered porch/open patio. Utilities include; high eff. gas furnace/central a/c, reverse osmosis drinking system. Neat/Clean Move-in Condition. Furnishings available with acceptable offer to Seller.