The median home value in Bay Shore, NY is $565,000.
This is
higher than
the county median home value of $490,000.
The national median home value is $308,980.
The average price of homes sold in Bay Shore, NY is $565,000.
Approximately 68.36% of Bay Shore homes are owned,
compared to 18.09% rented, while
13.64% are vacant.
Bay Shore real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you like to see a property, contact Bay Shore real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Learn more about Bay Shore.
Southward Estates Large Custom Built Center Hall Colonial Set On Largest Lot On Tern Court (1.1 Acres), 5 Bedroom, 3.5 Bath, EIK, FLR, Den w/FPL, Sunporch, Det 2 Car Garage, Entertainers Backyard w/Patio and Inground Pool.
Southward Estates Large Custom Built Center Hall Colonial Set On Largest Lot On Tern Court (1.1 Acres), 5 Bedroom, 3.5 Bath, EIK, FLR, Den w/FPL, Sunporch, Det 2 Car Garage, Entertainers Backyard w/Patio and Inground Pool.
Open House:
Saturday, 5/11 12:00-3:00PM
Beautiful Renovated Colonial in Bay Shore, close to all parkways & Shopping Centers, Featuring 3 Huge Bedrooms & 2 Full Renovated Bathrooms, Spacious Living Room and Dinning Area while Enjoying a Cozy Wood Fire Place at home. New Kitchen Cabinets and Quartz Countertops, Soft Close Cabinets & New Stainless Steel Appliances. Finished Basement with an Outside Separate Entrance Leading you to the Backyard. Spacious Wooden Deck for Entertainment, Lot size 50X100 with One Detached Car Garage. Taxes $9,320. Do not Miss This Opportunity!!
Open House:
Saturday, 5/11 12:00-3:00PM
Beautiful Renovated Colonial in Bay Shore, close to all parkways & Shopping Centers, Featuring 3 Huge Bedrooms & 2 Full Renovated Bathrooms, Spacious Living Room and Dinning Area while Enjoying a Cozy Wood Fire Place at home. New Kitchen Cabinets and Quartz Countertops, Soft Close Cabinets & New Stainless Steel Appliances. Finished Basement with an Outside Separate Entrance Leading you to the Backyard. Spacious Wooden Deck for Entertainment, Lot size 50X100 with One Detached Car Garage. Taxes $9,320. Do not Miss This Opportunity!!
Welcome to 121 Jordan St in Bay Shore with Islip School Zone --This expanded Hi Ranch offers 6 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths with gas heat , Hardwood floors do exist under carpets on second floor with eat in kitchen, Dining room. Living room and full bath Lower level features 2 entrances with Family room, Full Bath and 3 bedrooms . Al
Super Opportunity for buyers to bring your finishing touches to this 3 bedroom 2 bath home on large corner lot nearly half acre property with plenty of room to add pool or expand the house.Main level features 3 bedrooms, Living room/Dining Area with Full Bath. Basement for entertainment space has separate entrance on side of home. Home is located minutes from Long Island Railroad , Expressways, Shopping ,Schools, beaches and more !!
Open House:
Saturday, 5/11 12:00-2:00PM
Super Opportunity for buyers to bring your finishing touches to this 3 bedroom 2 bath home on large corner lot nearly half acre property with plenty of room to add pool or expand the house.Main level features 3 bedrooms, Living room/Dining Area with Full Bath. Basement for entertainment space has separate entrance on side of home. Home is located minutes from Long Island Railroad , Expressways, Shopping ,Schools, beaches and more !!
Open House:
Saturday, 5/11 12:00-2:00PM
Super Opportunity for buyers to bring your finishing touches to this 3 bedroom 2 bath home on large corner lot nearly half acre property with plenty of room to add pool or expand the house.Main level features 3 bedrooms, Living room/Dining Area with Full Bath. Basement for entertainment space has separate entrance on side of home. Home is located minutes from Long Island Railroad , Expressways, Shopping ,Schools, beaches and more !!
Welcome to 121 Jordan St in Bay Shore with Islip School Zone --This expanded Hi Ranch offers 6 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths with gas heat , Hardwood floors do exist under carpets on second floor with eat in kitchen, Dining room. Living room and full bath Lower level features 2 entrances with Family room, Full Bath and 3 bedrooms . Al
Welcome to 121 Jordan St in Bay Shore with Islip School Zone --This expanded Hi Ranch offers 6 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths with gas heat , Hardwood floors do exist under carpets on second floor with eat in kitchen, Dining room. Living room and full bath Lower level features 2 entrances with Family room, Full Bath and 3 bedrooms . Al
Open House:
Saturday, 5/18 9:00-11:00AM
Welcome to 1385 Gardiner Drive, a flexible 2 or 3 bedroom/2 full bath Ranch (both baths are newly updated) situated on .43 acre with mature landscaping, in-ground gunite pool, with new pump & solar cover, fire pit and an outdoor bar for your entertaining enjoyment! Eik with wood cabinetry, stainless appliances, marble counter top, pretty tile backsplash, formal dining room w/ fireplace, oversized living room with sliding doors to your outdoor oasis, full basement with laundry, storage & mechanicals. Brentwood schools, close to highways.
Open House:
Saturday, 5/18 9:00-11:00AM
Welcome to 1385 Gardiner Drive, a flexible 2 or 3 bedroom/2 full bath Ranch (both baths are newly updated) situated on .43 acre with mature landscaping, in-ground gunite pool, with new pump & solar cover, fire pit and an outdoor bar for your entertaining enjoyment! Eik with wood cabinetry, stainless appliances, marble counter top, pretty tile backsplash, formal dining room w/ fireplace, oversized living room with sliding doors to your outdoor oasis, full basement with laundry, storage & mechanicals. Brentwood schools, close to highways.
Open House:
Saturday, 5/11 1:00-3:00PM
Step into the heart of Bayshore, where this charming 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom Hi-Ranch home awaits. Overflowing with potential, this residence offers an exceptional opportunity for customization, allowing you to tailor your living space to your unique tastes. Conveniently situated near schools, parks, and shopping centers, this home ensures effortless access to essential amenities and recreational activities. Whether you're indulging in a leisurely stroll through the nearby park or running errands in town, everything you need is just moments away. Ideal for those with a vision and a desire to infuse their personal style, this property encourages you to unleash your creativity and turn it into your dream home. Don't let this opportunity slip away-seize the chance to make this house your own, crafting a space that truly reflects your lifestyle and preferences. With its abundance of potential and unbeatable location, this Bayshore gem is ready to welcome you home . Potential mother/daughter set up with proper permits.
Open House:
Saturday, 5/11 1:00-3:00PM
Step into the heart of Bayshore, where this charming 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom Hi-Ranch home awaits. Overflowing with potential, this residence offers an exceptional opportunity for customization, allowing you to tailor your living space to your unique tastes. Conveniently situated near schools, parks, and shopping centers, this home ensures effortless access to essential amenities and recreational activities. Whether you're indulging in a leisurely stroll through the nearby park or running errands in town, everything you need is just moments away. Ideal for those with a vision and a desire to infuse their personal style, this property encourages you to unleash your creativity and turn it into your dream home. Don't let this opportunity slip away-seize the chance to make this house your own, crafting a space that truly reflects your lifestyle and preferences. With its abundance of potential and unbeatable location, this Bayshore gem is ready to welcome you home . Potential mother/daughter set up with proper permits.
Cape 5 Br, living room, Kitchen, two full bathrooms, full finished basement ,don't miss the opportunity to own this property.
Cape 5 Br, living room, Kitchen, two full bathrooms, full finished basement ,don't miss the opportunity to own this property.
Open House:
Saturday, 5/11 11:00-1:00PM
Come see this beautifully renovated home. This home was renovated in 2024. Included in the renovation was a new roof and new electrical panel with 200 amp service. This home features brand new appliances including, refrigerator, dish washer, microwave, stove/oven, multiple air conditioning units, and water heater. The newly installed windows, kitchen sky light, and high hats offer a wonderful combination of natural and artificial light. The basement has been finished with a lovely carpet. Conveniently located between the Southern State Parkway and Sunrise Highway, this home allows for easy access to Long Islands major roadways. Also, providing close proximity to the ever increasingly popular main street in Bay Shore, this move in ready home is too good of an opportunity to miss.
Open House:
Friday, 5/10 5:00-7:00PM
Situated south of Montauk in Bay Shore, within the Islip School District, this two-bedroom, one-bath ranch offers practical living with lots of potential. The home includes an eat-in kitchen, the home is heated with oil and baseboard system, however, the property also has natural gas connected for the gas range and dryer. A rear deck and a detached 1 1/2 car garage complement the property, offering outdoor space and additional storage or workshop potential. The full, unfinished basement and the home's location-walking distance to shops and close to everything-make it a solid choice for those looking to invest in a property with the opportunity to customize and improve over time.
Open House:
Friday, 5/10 5:00-7:00PM
Situated south of Montauk in Bay Shore, within the Islip School District, this two-bedroom, one-bath ranch offers practical living with lots of potential. The home includes an eat-in kitchen, the home is heated with oil and baseboard system, however, the property also has natural gas connected for the gas range and dryer. A rear deck and a detached 1 1/2 car garage complement the property, offering outdoor space and additional storage or workshop potential. The full, unfinished basement and the home's location-walking distance to shops and close to everything-make it a solid choice for those looking to invest in a property with the opportunity to customize and improve over time.
With its gorgeous decks, flourishing gardens & sparkling ocean views, this beach house stands as a testament to the beauty of coastal living. Just one house off the ocean, beach access is just steps away. This Fair Harbor property exudes natural elegance, creating a harmonious blend between the indoor and outdoor spaces. The main floor, a haven of comfort and style, features two bedrooms, a full bath, a conveniently placed laundry area, a cozy living room with fireplace and a separate dining area. Sliding doors and expansive windows bring the light & picturesque outdoors in. A wide staircase leads up to the luxurious primary bedroom. Generously proportioned, bathed in natural light, with a full bath, a roomy closet, a designated workspace and room for lounging furniture, this space provides a perfect balance of functionality and indulgence. A private deck offers a tranquil spot to savor ocean views. In every detail, this residence embodies a harmonious blend of comfort, style, and the unparalleled beauty of coastal living. Most of all, this feels like home.
With its gorgeous decks, flourishing gardens & sparkling ocean views, this beach house stands as a testament to the beauty of coastal living. Just one house off the ocean, beach access is just steps away. This Fair Harbor property exudes natural elegance, creating a harmonious blend between the indoor and outdoor spaces. The main floor, a haven of comfort and style, features two bedrooms, a full bath, a conveniently placed laundry area, a cozy living room with fireplace and a separate dining area. Sliding doors and expansive windows bring the light & picturesque outdoors in. A wide staircase leads up to the luxurious primary bedroom. Generously proportioned, bathed in natural light, with a full bath, a roomy closet, a designated workspace and room for lounging furniture, this space provides a perfect balance of functionality and indulgence. A private deck offers a tranquil spot to savor ocean views. In every detail, this residence embodies a harmonious blend of comfort, style, and the unparalleled beauty of coastal living. Most of all, this feels like home.
Open House:
Saturday, 5/11 12:00-2:00PM
Located in Bay shore with Islip school district, this Hi-Ranch home offers an unparalleled combination of space and potential for a first-time home family or an investor. It has a lot of space for a big family, huge backyard and centrally located close to all shops, restaurants and more. Don't miss out this opportunity of potential real estate investment! Call today!
Open House:
Saturday, 5/11 12:00-2:00PM
Located in Bay shore with Islip school district, this Hi-Ranch home offers an unparalleled combination of space and potential for a first-time home family or an investor. It has a lot of space for a big family, huge backyard and centrally located close to all shops, restaurants and more. Don't miss out this opportunity of potential real estate investment! Call today!
INVESTER'S DELIGHT OR HOMEOWNER WITH 1/2 ACRE OF PROPERTY, MAIN HOUSE HAS 5 BEDROOMS AND 2 FULL BATHS, PARTIAL BASEMENT WITH 1 SEPARATE COTTAGE AND 1 STUDIO ALL ON 1/2 ACRE AND OWNER MOTIVATED. SURVEY IN OFFICE
INVESTER'S DELIGHT OR HOMEOWNER WITH 1/2 ACRE OF PROPERTY, MAIN HOUSE HAS 5 BEDROOMS AND 2 FULL BATHS, PARTIAL BASEMENT WITH 1 SEPARATE COTTAGE AND 1 STUDIO ALL ON 1/2 ACRE AND OWNER MOTIVATED. SURVEY IN OFFICE